Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 109 S Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344
Phone: (937) 679-5304
Website: https://pennylaneartcafe.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Penny Lane Art Gallery & Cafe | New Carlisle OH – Facebook
Send an inquiry at https://pennylaneartcafe.com/ Rent just the space, or we can cater it too with fully customizable sandwich and soup options! No matter which …
Food Menu – Penny Lane Art Gallery & Cafe
Our Menu Breakfast Served all day. Bacon & Egg Panini $6.25 Bacon, egg, cheddar cheese, and mayo, grilled on Texas toast.
Penny Lane Art Gallery & Cafe – Home
Located in the heart of New Carlisle, Ohio, Penny Lane Art Gallery and Coffee Shop offers cafe style food, drinks and beautiful artwork.
Reviews
Teena Gitzinger
Such a neat place. Saw advertisement for this neat little place on facebook. Aways ready to try something new and saw there October special seasonal flight. Looked so good. Sometimes When I go to different coffee shops I have a hard time choosing what to get because they all look so good and not sure what would be better. The latte flight let’s you try for different coffees. This day particular I had the 4 nine ounce samples of our Scary Berry Latte, Snickers Latte, Purple People Eater, and Pumpkin Donut Latte. All were so good. Purple people eater was what I was most excited to try but so glad I was able to try it this way. Was bummed that My that it was defently not for my taste buds. Not to say it might be for someone else . If you are a fan of extreme dark chocolate this is for you. But I still won for the other three were delicious and the food is amazing. Loved how the sandwiches were named after famous artist. Pretty neat. Prices are well worth it and the atmosphere was so neat. Will defently be making more trips here and ready to try more things. Let me not forget the customer service was right on too.
… moreElle M.
This was my 2nd visit to Pennylane and I am again in awe of the selections, the service and the peaceful atmosphere. The first time I came I popped in for lunch with a coworker and I just knew I had to come back. This time I brought family and it was a whole different menu from the coffee flight to the food and some how I was more deeply enthralled by the atmosphere and the flavors than before. We had such awesome encounters at that counters that after 3 hours of hanging out and trying a little bit of everything they had to offer from the Bananas Foster Bread to their B. E. L. T. (Customized for me with goat cheese) We got hugs from staff going off shift, because they were so wonderful at building rapport. The owner of the restaurant even came out and treated my family and I while serving us our 2nd round of treats and drinks and she remembered me from my first visit 4 months prior. And the art work makes it easy to sit and enjoy alone or use as conversation pieces with a group. I love Pennylane I hope they don’t change.
… moreKate Edmondson
This is a cute spot to meet a friend to
catch-up in downtown, nowhere Ohio. I loved my deviled egg sandwich but my partners tuna sandwich was just ok. The latte flight is raved about so that’s what we took the trip to try. The flavors were fun but very syrupy and we didn’t feel the usual caffeine hit we’d feel if we ordered a regular latte. I thought the place and menu were very thoughtfully curated and we will stop in again if we’re in the area.
… morecatch-up in downtown, nowhere Ohio. I loved my deviled egg sandwich but my partners tuna sandwich was just ok. The latte flight is raved about so that’s what we took the trip to try. The flavors were fun but very syrupy and we didn’t feel the usual caffeine hit we’d feel if we ordered a regular latte. I thought the place and menu were very thoughtfully curated and we will stop in again if we’re in the area.
Vivina Napier
Penny Lane is a unique hole-in-the-wall cafe just north of Dayton and, in my view, is a must-do if you’re in the area. The ambiance is so rich-chill boho meets art gallery vibes. It’s one of my favorite places to eat yummy and interesting sandwich takes, drink all the yummy seasonal coffee flavors and flights, meet with friends, sit and appreciate the art in this quaint little small town. It’s honestly the best.
… moreJennifer Ebright
I absolutely love this place! I usually try to stop by at least twice a week. They release a specialty menu every month with new, flavorful, and unique drinks and food, on top of their regular menu items. My favorite is the latte flights, which also change each month. The atmosphere is great and employees are super friendly. There is usually plenty of parking in the back. Highly recommend stopping by if you are in New Carlisle!
… moreTrash Wolf
Let me first say, I love this place. The vibe, the music, the decor. All dope.
It just took 54 minutes to get a shaken espresso drink, a full 30 minutes after my partner got her drink. After waiting 35 minutes, I got up to see if maybe they forgot, and they assured me it was coming, they were just short handed and busy.
I get. But 55 minutes for a coffee?
Just sayin. I love this place and will be back, but I gotta be fair.
… moreIt just took 54 minutes to get a shaken espresso drink, a full 30 minutes after my partner got her drink. After waiting 35 minutes, I got up to see if maybe they forgot, and they assured me it was coming, they were just short handed and busy.
I get. But 55 minutes for a coffee?
Just sayin. I love this place and will be back, but I gotta be fair.
Brooke Diviak Baykal
From the drinks, to the food, the atmosphere, and the service, this place really is great! The staff is welcoming, attentive, and helpful, and the owner is extremely kind and genuine. I highly recommend this local business and also recommend hosting your events there! They do event rentals and are so warm and helpful from the planning process through the event itself. We had a small wedding reception with family and it was the perfect place for it. Overall this place is wonderful and absolutely worth stopping in and checking out!
… moreMercedes May
Me and my friend have been coming here every month for about a year now and every time we are impressed by the amazing food and coffee flights ! We absolutely love coming here. Attached are just a few of the flights we’ve had!
… moreNicole Giles
Love Penny Lane! Great atmosphere, great fresh food and friendly service. Love their hot green tea, Georgia O Keef sandwich! Sitting area is not good for larger parties (>4 people). Only complaint is the drinks always come after the food (although they always turn up delicious) and sometimes their salad is not very fresh. For such a small place and kitchen, they sure do pump it out!
… moreChelsemae
We’ve been coming to Penny Lane since we moved here for about a year now. Our new coffee spot. The aesthetics of this establishment from the art, to the ambience are truly immaculate. Sure, you have your wait times and it CAN and WILL get busy on some days, but hey, c’mon y’all, if you are a true regular and know the vibe, you get it. If you’re not a regular, and are reading this, sometimes they have their moments of being busy! Patience is a virtue. 🙂
The seasonal menus are always fun, to the drinks down to the delicious food. My favorite so far, BY far, has got to be the BOOrito and the Birra flatbread pizza. Please bring that back sometime! I had gastric bypass over a year ago, and it’s hard to tolerate certain things and those two were greatly tolerated. I loved it so much.
When it has always come to trying to modify certain foods because of the change of foods I can eat now, you guys are great at helping me and giving suggestions.
I want to give a HUGGEEE special shout out to Toni!!! You are a gem, and absolutely amazing always making us feel welcome and taking care of us and the people here. You stay busy girl! I see you. Thank you for all you do!!!
To Ally, you have such an exceptional establishment.
Keep up the great work!!! Much love. xx
… moreThe seasonal menus are always fun, to the drinks down to the delicious food. My favorite so far, BY far, has got to be the BOOrito and the Birra flatbread pizza. Please bring that back sometime! I had gastric bypass over a year ago, and it’s hard to tolerate certain things and those two were greatly tolerated. I loved it so much.
When it has always come to trying to modify certain foods because of the change of foods I can eat now, you guys are great at helping me and giving suggestions.
I want to give a HUGGEEE special shout out to Toni!!! You are a gem, and absolutely amazing always making us feel welcome and taking care of us and the people here. You stay busy girl! I see you. Thank you for all you do!!!
To Ally, you have such an exceptional establishment.
Keep up the great work!!! Much love. xx