Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 23 Broadway St, Milton, PA 17847
Phone: (570) 742-4453
Website: https://www.originalitalianpizzamilton.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Original Italian Pizza – Milton, PA – 23 Broadway St – Hours, Menu …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-8:30 PM; Shop address is 23 Broadway St, Milton, PA 1784723 Broadway St, Milton, PA 17847; (570) 742-4453.
Original Italian Pizza – 23 Broadway St, Milton, PA 17847 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Milton, PA! Original Italian Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Oip Milton | Milton PA – Facebook
Oip Milton, Milton. 1026 likes · 3 talking about this · 2 were here. Italian Restaurant.
Last Updates
Reviews
Philly Yeard
Just ordered 12/20/25, the chicken bacon ranch is super good and the prices are good for the size of what you are getting.
… moreBenjamin
This is officially my favorite pizza shop, I think ever. Im newer to the area and have been looking for a quality shop that had good pie, subs and cheesesteaks. I’ve found a few that are pretty good, but nowhere compares to the Milton OIP..
I know OIP is a common name, but this one is by far the best ive ever eaten at.
Not only is the food fantastic, but the owner, Mario is a super nice, friendly person. It only took one time and one conversation for me to feel like a truly valued customer. The 2nd time I was ever in there, I was greeted by my first name and asked how my day is. That is a lost art these days and very rarely seen anymore.i dont know them that well, but I already consider them friends!
Now to the food. The absolute best marinara/pizza sauce ive ever had. Its simple, yet perfect for its application. It pairs excellent with their homemade bread and pies. The homemade breads is next. Absolutely perfect homemade bread/rolls for their subs. Always cooked to the perfect consistency and flavor! The pie is absolutely fantastic. Again, amazing sauce, paired with perfect dough and just the right amount of cheese. What could be better? I recently tried the zucchini fries, very good and a nice change up from the normal stuff. I havent had them yet, but they have pictures hanging of their Italian dinners and wow, do they ever look amazing! Looking forward to dining in with the wife very soon and getting an authentic Italian dinner.!
The staff is always friendly and the prices are good especially for the portions, not too mention the quality. Stop in and see Mario and enjoy some amazing pizza and subs!
… moreI know OIP is a common name, but this one is by far the best ive ever eaten at.
Not only is the food fantastic, but the owner, Mario is a super nice, friendly person. It only took one time and one conversation for me to feel like a truly valued customer. The 2nd time I was ever in there, I was greeted by my first name and asked how my day is. That is a lost art these days and very rarely seen anymore.i dont know them that well, but I already consider them friends!
Now to the food. The absolute best marinara/pizza sauce ive ever had. Its simple, yet perfect for its application. It pairs excellent with their homemade bread and pies. The homemade breads is next. Absolutely perfect homemade bread/rolls for their subs. Always cooked to the perfect consistency and flavor! The pie is absolutely fantastic. Again, amazing sauce, paired with perfect dough and just the right amount of cheese. What could be better? I recently tried the zucchini fries, very good and a nice change up from the normal stuff. I havent had them yet, but they have pictures hanging of their Italian dinners and wow, do they ever look amazing! Looking forward to dining in with the wife very soon and getting an authentic Italian dinner.!
The staff is always friendly and the prices are good especially for the portions, not too mention the quality. Stop in and see Mario and enjoy some amazing pizza and subs!
Devin
I have asked multiple times for well done pizza. I even asked if they knew what well done was. They said yes after I said it means to cook it longer. After multiple times I’ve never gotten well done and in fact have gotten the opposite. I don’t like doughy pizza, maybe people like it but I’m not a fan. Just listen it’s not difficult. Not one thing cooked well done.
… moreKevin Gehsmann
What a great lunch spot I stumbled into while passing through town. Incredibly fresh bread for my delicious chicken parm sandwich. Good salad. Great service and great chatting with Mario!
… moreRoger Saddler
By Far the best steak sandwich I have ever had. They make the sandwich bread it was a must stop if traveling 80 in PA. I have eaten alot of restaurants this is one of the best.
… moreEric Von
On our way to Williamsport we stopped at this place spur of the moment and I’m glad we did. The lasagna was delicious and the server Lexi was excellent.
… moreLindy Folk
Met with family…all of us from out of town…. This place is a gem…wings were amazing, next entree chicken salad delicious and plentiful, stuff shells just like what I grew up with in a Scilian neighborhood, chicken sandwich and fries tender and juicy!
… moreYvonne Lunsford
I had my order delivered. The portions were amazing. Everything was delicious and honestly, there is enough left overs to feed me for 2 more days. Wonderful. I’ll definitely order here again.
… moreWendy Kroll
Oh wow. Stopped here on our way to NYC from Michigan – what a delightful little gem. Owner’s family is from Sicily – gracious hosts. Sauce is to die for. Absolutely delicious and very reasonably priced. Will return on our way back for sure!
… moreBrit
Always so nice and professional! The food is always great. Definitely a must for those nights when you just don’t want to make dinner.
… more