Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Thin-crust & deep-dish pizzas, plus salads & sandwiches, served in a brick-lined storefront.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1438 Yankee Doodle Rd, Eagan, MN 55121
Phone: (651) 452-4525
Website: https://www.italianpieshoppe.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Italian Pie Shoppe serves award-winning pizza, pasta, and …
*Lunch Delivery: Mon, Thur, Fri, Sat 11am-1pm *Dinner Delivery: Mon-Thur 5-6:30pm. Fri-Sat 5-7:30pm *Sundays: Noon-6:30pm · *Delivery Fee: $2.00 · $15 minimum ( …
The Italian Pie Shoppe – Eagan
The Italian Pie Shoppe – Eagan Menu. APPETIZERS; SALADS; PASTA; SANDWICHES; BUILD YOUR OWN; CALZONES & STROMBOLI; THIN CRUST PIZZA; DEEP DISH PIZZA; STUFFED …
Italian Pie Shop – Eagan, Minnesota – Menu, prices, restaurant reviews
Italian Pie Shop, Eagan, MN. 212 likes · 4 talking about this · 2575 were here. Pizza place.
Reviews
Michael Ross
We’ve been coming here for over 15 years, but not as often as we used to. We’ve heard that ownership had changed hands and thought we’d see if anything was different. I’ve always enjoyed their pizza, but the sauce would have an after taste I didn’t care for. We went in and pretty much everything was as it always was. We were seated right away and the waitress was very friendly. We ordered 2 pizzas and we were all pleasantly surprised that the sauce no longer had the odd after taste. Even the kids enjoyed it and they can be pretty picky. The only thing that would’ve been better would be a little more sauce. So if you’re a sauce lover, make sure to order extra sauce here.
… moreBrad Ruehle
Cozy family feel spot. I had a calzone, and it was prepared quickly. It was simple, Sausage, Pepperoni, and Jalapeños. Great atmosphere. Definitely a place to try.
… moreTanya Howard
Delicious food! Great atmosphere and service. Cute little restaurant! And super cute jarr glasses.
… moreLisa Carmichael
Had a wonderful family experience at the Italian Pie Shoppe here in Eagan. Our server was friendly and did a great job serving us. The pies were a great value—large and delicious. We also tried the meatball appetizer and enjoyed that as well. We opted for thin crust pizza and they didn’t disappoint. The venue was fun with some great history to enjoy. Plenty of seating. Such a great experience for our family. Great business in Eagan.
… moreJacob McNamara
We were tired of the usual pizza on Friday night with the family so we decided to give them a try after running some errands. We ordered takeout and even though they were packed full, we still had our large Order ready in 20 min! It was delicious! Our kids are usually picky but they absolutely loved it as well! The sauce is absolutely amazing, definitely the highlight! We will definitely be back! Thank you!!!
… moreCarolina D
Had the Chicago torpedo, which was excellent. They also had a banana drink on the dessert menu. It’s alcoholic And tastes just like banana cream pie! You have to try it. Aaron is absolutely awesome and our server Elena was super nice and provided great service. We will definitely be back.
… moreMollie Joy
To begin, I should have gotten a Deep-Dish , but I didn’t want to wait the 30-45 minutes because we had craft shows to get to. I love deep dish and that probably would have been better. For me, it’s SO hard to outdo Red’s Savoy thin crust, and these pies didn’t do it. The was boring, and the ranch wasn’t great, but it was a good value for $5.00. The pizzas themselves were okay, though the Margherita version here was the strangest I’ve seen. Where is the fresh basil? Where are the globs of fresh mozzarella? Neither of those are included in the description, but that’s what I expect and not the reality that we got.
This place has been on my list for years, so I’m sort of bummed it wasn’t better. It’s got an old school vibe that I really enjoyed, and our waitress was talkative and friendly despite being the only one working that day. I will say that the booths are TIGHT. Thankfully, the seats move a bit, but if that’s a concern for you, I recommend heading to a table.
… moreThis place has been on my list for years, so I’m sort of bummed it wasn’t better. It’s got an old school vibe that I really enjoyed, and our waitress was talkative and friendly despite being the only one working that day. I will say that the booths are TIGHT. Thankfully, the seats move a bit, but if that’s a concern for you, I recommend heading to a table.
Debby Etoll
Our church ladies had a luncheon there. 40 of us and we all enjoyed it. The staff did a great job of preparing our food and serving it. I had the Chicago torpedo and it was delicious! I will definitely eat there again.
… morePaul A
I’ve been a customer of the Eagan location for more than 30 years driving all the way from far west Bloomington because the pizza was so good. I always order thin crust pizza. The sauce has always been the best around. I hadn’t been there since May 2025. This time (October 2025) the sauce seemed like plain Hunts Tomato Sauce — no seasonings whatever — and the cheese and toppings tasted bland. Unsure of why, when i got home and researched — discovered the business was sold May 2025. It”s not the same anymore. Don’t think I’ll ever go back.
EDIT: As a long time customer, I decided to go back to give them another chance. I was happily surprised my pizza was made to the original recipe. Whether the visit prompting my negative review was an unfortunate lapse, or some negative reviews sent them back to the traditional recipe, I’ll now not give up on them. I’ve changed my 1-star review to a 4-star review.
… moreEDIT: As a long time customer, I decided to go back to give them another chance. I was happily surprised my pizza was made to the original recipe. Whether the visit prompting my negative review was an unfortunate lapse, or some negative reviews sent them back to the traditional recipe, I’ll now not give up on them. I’ve changed my 1-star review to a 4-star review.
Scott Clark
We’ve been eating here for more than 30 years now and it’s our favorite pizza restaurant. They’ve had ownership and staff changes in recent years, but the food quality has never wavered. We supported them with take out orders during COVID because we didn’t want them to close, but they were always busy on the few days that they were open during that time, so that was nice. Highly recommend the Italian Pie Shoppe!
… more