Hours
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1545 E Iron Eagle Dr, Eagle, ID 83616
Phone: (208) 202-2897
Website: http://papakelseyssubs.toast.site/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Papa Kelsey’s: Home
Papa Kelsey’s currently has locations in Idaho, Colorado & Arizona. … You would be correct. OUR STORY. Papa Kelsey’s Subs & Salads Logo …
Menu – Papa Kelsey’s
Papa Kelsey’s. Papa Kelsey’s. 0. Order Now. Sign in. Menu. 1545 E Iron Eagle Dr , Suite 107, Eagle, ID. Change location. Subs. Pizzas. Salads. Sides. Drinks.
Papa Kelsey’s Subs & Salads – MapQuest
1545 E Iron Eagle Dr, Eagle, ID, 83616. Papa Kelsey’s Subs & Salads specializes in handmade dough that is crafted fresh every day, ensuring a delightful …
Reviews
Tucker Barker
We got the chicken bacon ranch and the chicken Malibu subs. Preferred the Malibu but both were stellar and the bread was great!
We got the mozzarella sticks and they were pretty good. The pepperoni pizza was good too.
Service was great, not busy at all but the folks working were super friendly.
… moreWe got the mozzarella sticks and they were pretty good. The pepperoni pizza was good too.
Service was great, not busy at all but the folks working were super friendly.
Camden Mcallister
Service was ok, food was boring, skimpy and light on flavor. I had brisket which was thin and bread taste like soda cracker. Daughters turkey sandwich was plain and boring and very thin with almost no flavor or sauce. Salad was ok but skimpy. For the price you dont get much food.
… moreJake Bowman
I stopped in at Papa Kelsey’s in Eagle and ordered the Italian Combo—and wow, it was absolutely delicious. The bread alone was a game-changer—soft, flavorful, and clearly made fresh in-house. You can taste the difference when a place makes their own bread, and Papa Kelsey’s nails it.
What really made the visit even better was chatting with the owner, Sam. He’s genuine, passionate about what he does, and proud to be part of a true Idaho-local company. You can feel the hometown pride in both the food and the service.
If you’re in the area and craving a sandwich that hits all the right notes—flavor, freshness, and good vibes—this is the spot. Support local and eat something awesome. Highly recommend!
… moreWhat really made the visit even better was chatting with the owner, Sam. He’s genuine, passionate about what he does, and proud to be part of a true Idaho-local company. You can feel the hometown pride in both the food and the service.
If you’re in the area and craving a sandwich that hits all the right notes—flavor, freshness, and good vibes—this is the spot. Support local and eat something awesome. Highly recommend!
Alicia Barkell
Absolutely delicious! From the freshly made croutons and cheesy bread to the incredible pizza, everything was full of flavor. The restaurant is spotless and full of natural light, making it a great place to enjoy a meal. If you haven’t been to Papa Kelsey’s yet, you’re missing out! And don’t leave without trying their giant, freshly made cinnamon rolls—they’re amazing! ❤️
… moreCody Laws
Did an online order about 30 minutes before I showed up and it didn’t show up in their system so I had to wait for them to cook it get the pizza go home open it up and what I see is l/4 of this pizza has no topping , For the price I’d expect the quality be a lot better this is unacceptable the other Pizza I ordered was fine
… moreEmily Huttash
This place is great!! Clean, open, relaxed atmosphere, delicious food and fast friendly service. Hubby and I shared a personal pizza, a sub and onion rings. Definitely more food than we needed, but glad we tried them all! Ingredients were fresh, cooked perfectly and the flavor combinations were fantastic. None of the food was greasy or heavy like a lot of onion rings, pizza and hot subs can be. We will definitely come back!!
… moreL Zappa (A Google User)
excited to try the new place that took the place of our beloved Chicago connection. They have a lot more menu options than they did . We called a couple weeks ago and were put off by the rude and short person on the phone . Still tried it tonight . Pizza was actually ok . I liked it . But the onion rings burned . Think of the turkey In Lampoons Christmas vacation . Forgot sauce I paid for . Not great unfortunately and Eagle needs options like this . I was surprised by all the great reviews after our 2 experiences. Maybe we are just getting a bad shift ♀️
… moreAnne Banks
Ordered the whole Malibu chicken sub. I could only finish 1/4, the amount of toppings was very generous. The bread is delicious! The staff were super friendly! Great sandwich, pizza and salad options! So exciting to have them here!
… moreKristen McCarver
Food is awesome, restaurant facility itself is clean and bright! Took away one star for the disgusting greasy plates , and the staff who didn’t seem to care. No smiles or greeting when we came in, nor when they served our food. We literally had to ask for the drink cups that we ordered, and they brought us one fork for three people who ordered wings. We love the food, we love the convenience of the location, one tweak to staff culture would go a very long way to adding that last star.
… moreJonathan Joerg
Mediocre at best. Got the half Italian with half a cheese bread. The sub was so-so, nothing to write home to mom about. The cheese bread was flavorless. The ticket came to a little over $19.00. I would consider this order to be worth around $8-$10 total (that’s being generous).
… more