Creative sushi with an acclaimed chef’s choice omakase menu in a prime Theater District location.
Sila Gunn
We discovered this lovely sushi restaurant by chance on the west side. We had a really pleasant and high-quality experience. The staff’s attentiveness and the flavors were beyond expectations. This will definitely be my go-to spot whenever I come to this neighborhood.
… moreKaterina
Very good sushi in midtown west. I appreciate that each piece is a great cut, so you definitely are leaving satisfied. The restaurant also offers omakase and multiple interesting appetizers. Service is great. The place is not very big and more on the casual side. They also offer great lunch special, used to be my favorite nice lunch spot when I lived and worked in the area.
… morejade
Woof. Unbelievably overpriced for what you get, and what you get is 12 pieces of sushi with ZERO finesse. Just sloppy and weak flavours. These look okay, but they were indeed just okay. Their fish quality is good but you’re paying 160 dollars for 12 pieces….. it better be good quality at least. But for that price the experience should be amazing, and it was soooo not at all. What is amazing is that they are charging this price. I will pay 200-400 for a good omakase i rly dont care because it can be so worth it, this is so not.
The lights are so bright it makes you want to shrink back its almost like being in an interrogation room i really dont feel like im exaggerating that much.
Terrible ambiance so so bad that would be reason to never go back but with the sushi being so subpar at the price point. Just avoid.
… moreBlake Ogden
I had an incredible dining experience at Sushi of Gari 46. From the moment I walked in, the service was outstanding. The sushi chef was exceptionally kind and welcoming, which made the experience feel personal and authentic. The staff was attentive without being intrusive, ensuring that I had everything I needed throughout the meal.
The ambience struck a perfect balance between elegance and comfort. The minimalist yet warm décor gave it an authentic Japanese feel, and the atmosphere was calm and inviting — ideal for an intimate sushi experience.
Now, the highlight: the sushi. The variety of flavors and textures was truly remarkable. Each piece was beautifully presented and thoughtfully crafted, showcasing the freshness of the ingredients. The toro nigiri topped with caviar was a standout — the buttery richness of the fish paired perfectly with the briny pop of the caviar. The uni hand roll was another highlight; the creamy, sweet uni contrasted beautifully with the crisp nori and perfectly seasoned rice.
Every bite felt like a harmonious balance of flavor and texture. It’s clear that a lot of attention goes into both the sourcing of ingredients and the preparation of each piece.
If you’re a sushi lover, Sushi of Gari 46 is a must-visit. The combination of top-notch service, authentic atmosphere, and outstanding food makes this place a true gem. I can’t wait to go back!
… moreArina Zudenko
I’ve been coming here for over 10 years, and it has truly become part of my weekly routine. The quality has always been consistent, the service is outstanding, and the staff go above and beyond to make every visit a positive experience. It’s rare to find a place that maintains such high standards year after year. Always reliable, always welcoming, and always amazing highly recommend!
… moreBoris Nemirov
Yes, Sushi of Gari 46 is very expensive, especially if you get the signature omakase. However, the quality and taste of what you get is incredible. Ingredients are top notch and the preparation and presentation are outstanding. It is a special and rare treat. Service is fine and the decor is nothing too impressive, but their sushi is so very good. Even something as simple as a tuna roll, just melts in your mouth.
… more清川仁
I can say this restaurant is one you should visit if you are in NY and look for a sushi restaurant. They serve authentic sushi and also very modernized sushi. You can enjoy classic and innovative sushi both. Also I enjoyed the atmosphere of them. Very clean, cozy, and authentic Japanese restaurant atmosphere are there. I can say you won’t regret to eat their sushi. They also have affordable sushi around 40 bucks.
… moreGloria Kim
DELICIOUS!!
My husband and I made a reservation for 2 at 6pm on a Wednesday night. I highly recommend making reservations because they can get busy.
The servers were very attentive and knowledgeable. Everything was super clean and the sushi was really fresh. I thought the price point was very affordable. We did a-la-carte and thought that it was totally worth the price.
We ordered the Gari Special which consisted of 8 different fish. Each were all tender and fresh. They were also with soy sauce and wasabi so we were advised not to dip it in additional wasbai/soy sauce. Each bite was delicious and the fish were melt in my mouth good.
Their cut rolls were SO good. I kept reaching for more and more even if I was so full. My favorite was the Fatty Tuna roll with scallions. I could probably eat that every day.
ALSO, their uni from Japan was delicious!!! It wasn’t very “fishy” compared to other places that get them from a lower quality place. Their uni was creamy and rich in flavor.
OK- I honestly had a really great time at Sushi of Gari. Price point was good, sushi was fresh, the servers were super attentive, overall a really great time.
I cant wait to go back for some more of their Fatty Tuna roll.
… moreR C
What an absolute gem this place is! Came pre-show and had the best time. The food was all incredible (we ate lots of rolls). The staff were so attentive and friendly. Having overheard my friend wish me a happy birthday, unprovoked they brought me a delicious matcha ice cream desert with a candle and the whole place sang. It was so nice. Will always come back here! Thank you!!!
… moreRoee Adler
What an incredible sushi experience! I took the sushi omakase at the bar, each bite was simply perfect, couldn’t recommend more.
… more