Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1908 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601
Phone: (717) 519-1919
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Caruso’s Pizzeria
LOCATIONS ; Neffsville. 2719 Lititz Pike. Neffsville, PA. 717-569-7989 ; Silver Springs. 3545 Marietta Avenue. Lancaster, PA 17601. 717-285-3885 ; Willow Street.
Home – Caruso’s on Fruitville
Carusos is a family owned business serving the best pizza in lancaster county since 1982. This Location on 1908 fruitville pike was opened in 2010.
Caruso’s Italian Restaurant – Lancaster, PA 17601 (Menu & Order …
Online ordering menu for Caruso’s Italian Restaurant. Here at Caruso’s Italian Restaurant (Silver Springs), we serve cuisine such as Regular Boli, …
Reviews
Mel
The food is ok they got my order wrong I asked for no mayo and still got mayo no big deal though. The first time I had the turkey panini and it was great but the second time was pretty disappointing. I think they have a bit of a consistency problem might have something to do with all the young people working. I felt rushed when I placed my order over the phone that was probably why they missed me saying no mayo. It’s an ok place just wish it was more consistent.
… moreJames Stewart
Ordered pizza and cheesesteaks for our Super Bowl party and honestly… this place delivered a championship performance.
The pizza showed up hot, fresh, and perfectly cooked — crispy crust, plenty of cheese, and loaded with toppings. Every slice disappeared fast, which tells you everything you need to know. Even after sitting out during the game, it still tasted amazing.
Now the cheesesteaks… absolute game-changers. The rolls were fresh and soft, the meat was packed in and seasoned perfectly, and the cheese was melted just right. Not greasy, not dry — just straight-up legit. Multiple people asked where we ordered from and went back for seconds (and thirds).
Everything was ready on time, packaged well, and made hosting easy. When you’re feeding a house full of hungry football fans, that matters. No stress, no complaints — just great food and a great night.
If you’re planning a party and want food that everyone will rave about, this is the spot. They definitely helped make our Super Bowl party a win. Will 100% order again.
… moreThe pizza showed up hot, fresh, and perfectly cooked — crispy crust, plenty of cheese, and loaded with toppings. Every slice disappeared fast, which tells you everything you need to know. Even after sitting out during the game, it still tasted amazing.
Now the cheesesteaks… absolute game-changers. The rolls were fresh and soft, the meat was packed in and seasoned perfectly, and the cheese was melted just right. Not greasy, not dry — just straight-up legit. Multiple people asked where we ordered from and went back for seconds (and thirds).
Everything was ready on time, packaged well, and made hosting easy. When you’re feeding a house full of hungry football fans, that matters. No stress, no complaints — just great food and a great night.
If you’re planning a party and want food that everyone will rave about, this is the spot. They definitely helped make our Super Bowl party a win. Will 100% order again.
Ray Metzger II
Food was cooked, prepared & tasted great!!! Marinara is 1 of the better 1s I’ve had, homemade bread, fresh lettuce, o’s. Seasoning was present!!! Bathrooms need some love & the counter folks while pleasant & asked me how the food was (this is so appreciated) we’re giggling, on phones. There was active cleaning going on which is something you rarely see anywhere anymore.
… moreBrad Bertinot
The best pizza in Lancaster hands down. Great service, fresh ingredients, and the perfect dough! The staff is amazing too!
… moreElena *
Menu has a huge selection to choose from with many delicious options.
Here’s a few of my go to:
*Margarita Pizza (family favorite)
*Chic cheese steak
*Shrimp basket with fries
*Chic. spinach calzone (family’s favorite)
*Greek salad with grill chic.
*Meat lovers Sicilian pizza
Pleasant staff, clean
… moreHere’s a few of my go to:
*Margarita Pizza (family favorite)
*Chic cheese steak
*Shrimp basket with fries
*Chic. spinach calzone (family’s favorite)
*Greek salad with grill chic.
*Meat lovers Sicilian pizza
Pleasant staff, clean
Charlie R
I have never been to a Caruso’s before but have been wanting to try it every time I pass them. Well I finally stopped in with my wife and son and we were not disappointed. The service was beyond amazing and very friendly as well. The BBQ Chicken Cheesesteak was maybe one of the best Iv ever had. The garlic knots and Broccoli were mouthwatering! Will be definitely coming back soon.
… moreRaj
If you’re in Lancaster, PA and Caruso Pizzeria is a must-visit spot! Known for its exceptionally clean and welcoming atmosphere, Caruso Pizzeria offers a friendly environment where customers feel right at home. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick lunch or bringing the family for dinner, the staff always greets you with a smile and top-notch service.
Caruso Pizzeria takes pride in serving quality food at reasonable prices, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The menu is packed with mouthwatering options, but two standouts you absolutely have to try are the veggie stromboli and the classic cheese pizza. The veggie stromboli is loaded with fresh, flavorful vegetables and wrapped in perfectly baked dough — it’s a satisfying option even meat lovers will enjoy. As for the cheese pizza, it’s a simple masterpiece. With its crisp crust, rich tomato sauce, and gooey, melted mozzarella, it’s the kind of pizza that keeps you coming back for more.
Not only is the food consistently great, but the cleanliness of the restaurant truly sets it apart. Tables are spotless, the kitchen is well-maintained, and you can always count on a sanitary, safe dining experience.
Caruso Pizzeria is a true gem in Lancaster. Whether you’re dining in, ordering takeout, or grabbing a slice on the go, this place delivers in taste, service, and value. Don’t miss out — stop by and treat yourself to the best stromboli and cheese pizza in town!
… moreCaruso Pizzeria takes pride in serving quality food at reasonable prices, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The menu is packed with mouthwatering options, but two standouts you absolutely have to try are the veggie stromboli and the classic cheese pizza. The veggie stromboli is loaded with fresh, flavorful vegetables and wrapped in perfectly baked dough — it’s a satisfying option even meat lovers will enjoy. As for the cheese pizza, it’s a simple masterpiece. With its crisp crust, rich tomato sauce, and gooey, melted mozzarella, it’s the kind of pizza that keeps you coming back for more.
Not only is the food consistently great, but the cleanliness of the restaurant truly sets it apart. Tables are spotless, the kitchen is well-maintained, and you can always count on a sanitary, safe dining experience.
Caruso Pizzeria is a true gem in Lancaster. Whether you’re dining in, ordering takeout, or grabbing a slice on the go, this place delivers in taste, service, and value. Don’t miss out — stop by and treat yourself to the best stromboli and cheese pizza in town!
Eric Usbeck
Frank catered our collegiate swim team meals for a whole weekend competition. He was tremendous with creating a menu of great food that was enjoyed by everyone! Very easy to work with. He is also very kind and helpful. Food was great, surely would recommend to anyone in the area!
… moreKevin C
Wow! Just stopped on here while traveling through the area. What a great cheesesteak. The bread was amazing!!! Clean place and friendly staff.. will for sure be back
… moreCJ Bird
Decent regular pie, decent prices/lunch special. I would grab a slice if I’m in the area and need a bite to eat. I wouldn’t go out of my way for it. It’s mostly a pick up to go place. There was a very small area to eat. I didn’t care for their Sicilian style pizza though, wouldn’t order that again.
… more