Casual neighborhood joint offering a broad menu of sandwiches, soups & salads, plus housebaked pies.
Damon
My wife and I stopped by Yesterdays Sandwich Shop around 3:25 PM, about 35 minutes before they closed at 4:00 PM. I ordered a ham sandwich and the soup of the day, which was baked potato—but unfortunately, they had already run out of the soup.
The ham sandwich was very good—fresh, flavorful, and satisfying. My wife had the chicken salad sandwich and really enjoyed hers as well. Both sandwiches were tasty and well-prepared.
The only downside was that it felt like we were being rushed to eat and leave. The two employees working were already busy with their closing duties while we were still dining, which made the experience feel a bit hurried.
That said, we would still recommend Yesterdays Sandwich Shop if you’re looking for a good, casual meal. Just try to get there well before closing time to enjoy a more relaxed visit and full menu options.
… moreMarie P
I’ve enjoyed Yesterdays Sandwich Shop for the past seven years through delivery, pick-up, and dining in—and every experience has been excellent. The food is consistently fresh and flavorful, and the service is always friendly and efficient.
The sourdough bread is absolutely perfect—crusty on the outside, soft on the inside. I highly recommend the Brown Bag Special; it’s a great value and always hits the spot. And don’t skip dessert—everything I’ve tried has been delicious.
Highly recommend this place whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or sitting down for a relaxed lunch. A local gem!
… moreNaomi Tiddark
I was working in Weatherford and needed a quick bite — so glad I stopped at Yesterday’s Sandwich Shop! I came around 1 PM and it was pretty busy, but the wait wasn’t bad at all. The food was fresh, flavorful, and very affordable. This is definitely my new go-to whenever I’m in the area!
… moreBrooke Barton
Love this place! Bread is soooo good! I had the BLT, my fave! My sister had chicken salad sandwich & chicken tortilla soup. Momma had a BLT & vegetable soup. The peach tea is wonderful as well! We love coming here!
… moreVeronica G
Such a cute sandwich shop. Food is amazing! They have the best chicken salad I’ve ever tasted! Still thinking about it now! Sourdough bread and chicken salad made fresh daily! I will return every time I’m in Weatherford! I confirmed about schedule and they do Not open early for breakfast in Weatherford. They open Monday-Saturday 10:30 am -4:00 pm.
… moreElla Canfield
I catered yesterdays for my daughters birthday, about 40 people. Everything was amazing! From the timing, to service, to the sandwhiches themselves! Everything was easy and efficient. I couldn’t recommend enough! Thank yall so much!
… moreHayli Castillo
It’s been years since I had been to yesterdays and I was so excited. The food was just as amazing as I remember. The peach tea is sooo good. The bread is delicious! The peach cobbler is amazing. The lady taking our order was a bit rude and the location is much much smaller than I remember.
… moreTimothy Webster
Great sandwich location. It is loud (I have a hearing aid) and conversations can be challenging. Otherwise, it is a wonderful meal…very good gluten-free bread is available, but the homemade sourdough is wonderful!!
… moreMaegan Hull
I went by for my second time ever. I went once years ago with my mom. That sourdough bread is not true sourdough. It’s crumbly and resembles regular white bread but with a sweetness to it. It almost resembles Hawaiian sweet rolls but in sandwich bread form. Aside from that, I ordered the spicy Turkey bacon ranch. I had studied the menu before I went inside so that I wouldn’t hold up the line. I was supposed to have a warm melted sandwich with jalapeño sourdough bread, Turkey, jalapeño, bacon and ranch (according to the descriptions on the menu available online.) I ended up with whatever kind of non jalapeño bread that was, cold Turkey, cold cheese and room temp bacon with a splat of ranch. Highly disappointing. I also found a black hair in it, looked to be like dog or pet hair, so I’m sure it was transferred from clothing worn to work from home that had residual animal hair on it. So gross!! I ordered it to go and should have checked it before I left the shop. Lesson learned.
… moreJonathan Newcom
Hands down the best sandwich under $10 I’ve ever had (The Italian). It was close to closing time, or I would’ve been forced to order about 5 more for the road. Honestly I can’t stop thinking about how good the homemade bread is.
… more