Adam Amick
We come to Firehouse Pizza in Casper all the time, and the Bee’s Knees with hot honey is hands-down the best pizza here — we get it every single time. Today we were craving lemonade, and this is easily the best spot in Casper for it. We grabbed a regular and a strawberry lemonade, and both were perfect. Prices are more than fair — just the other day we paid double somewhere else for pizza with way worse ingredients. Firehouse is always consistent, delicious, and worth the trip. 10/10 recommend. Best pizza in Casper, Wyoming (and honestly, maybe anywhere).
… moreMiguel Angel Matos
Driving thru and needed a quick but satisfying dinner.
Ordered, The Chief pizza and ten piece chicken wings.
They were awesome!
Specially the pizza. You could taste all the fresh ingredients.
I ordered thru their website not realizing it was five minutes to closing.
Then called to confirm. They were very friendly and accommodating considering their phone system was having problems.
Took them about ten minutes to get my order ready. By the time I drove there, it was ready.
Very clean facility and easy parking.
The price was a great deal for the fresh and well seasoned food.
The cheese and the honey in the pizza worked very well together as well as you could taste them on its own.
… morepaige sanchez
Pizza’s great. But if you’re gonna have some great, take orders, they should probably be a little more customer friendly. And not be so rude
… moreRobert Nickerson
The pizza we had was pretty good, but the cheese sticks were not worth getting. The chicken wings were tasty as well, but the buffalo sauce was too oily. Also, they advertised beer, but the store lost its liquor license and couldn’t serve anything more than soda.
Again, not bad, but we won’t be going back.
… moreJuan from San Juan
Solid pizza! Wood fire style toasty pizza crust! Very competitive prices. This place is in a shopping center parking lot, so plenty of parking space. Maybe about 12 tables. No servers, so just order, pay, and they’ll call your name when its ready.
… moreT Marie
I’m sad I didn’t find this spot sooner- the order was made crazy fast, the cashier and line cook were both so sweet, and the pizza was outstanding. I got a takeout pepperoni and mushroom hand tossed pizza and a lemonade. 10/10, definitely coming back!
Worth adding for those looking over reviews – the owners takes feedback seriously and reaches out if things go wrong. Big deal in my book when considering who to give my business to. Good on ya, Firehouse crew. You have yourself a new fan. ❤️
… moreAnnalee R
Wow. Everything about this place is so great! We visited from out of town when it was slow and got a chance to talk with the owner. He was very personable and friendly and gave us good suggestions about the pizza, drinks, wings and garlic bread.
We got cheese pizza for the kids, the Towering Inferno pizza for us and a 10 piece order of wings. Delicious! All of it! I highly recommend the Towering Inferno and the wings.
The restaurant was also super clean, including the bathrooms.
Update- our family was traveling through Casper again this weekend and HAD to stop at Firehouse Pizza. It’s THAT good! The garlic cheese bread was terrific. We had the wings with the dry rub as well as another order with garlic Parmesan. Delicious!
… moreDenise Bunch
Better than the standard takeout places but disappointing. Super thin crust- very plain cracker like . Not much flavor and crust cooked well done before the cheese was fully melted. If cheese was melted it would be a good appetizer among other things offered. Probably won’t return. If you’re sitting down there are better pizza places in Casper for same $ when size is considered (Firehouse is personal size).
… moreJennica Rowland
Loved the atmosphere and the staff were so friendly, but most of all.. that pizza was amazing!!!
… moreSchpri Roszel
The staff is INCREDIBLE! So helpful and kind!
The food is amazing and unique! The atmosphere is comfortable and the entire place is clean and constantly being cleaned. I love this place! Signed up for their loyalty program and got a free dessert pizza! It made my entire day! Highly recommend them! ❤️
… more