Jason F
Based on a recommendation, I tried Valentino’s last night for the 1st time and loved it. The pizza was just the way I like it. Thin, crispy crust just like a great NY style pizza. The bartender, Mikayla was super friendly and pleasant to chat with as well. They’re definitely going to get my business from here on out. Well done!
… moreJoey Clearman
Came here to celebrate Mother’s Day early and was surprised that it was Texas State Graduation Day. Our server was very nice and have us great service despite being swamped. Did was quick, hot and delicious. Garlic knots were perfect, classic fluffy and chewy. My wife had a sandwich and it was awesome she said. I shared a large pizza with the kids. It has great crust, cooked perfectly. Great crunch and chew. One of the best new York style pizza in the area.
… moreJessica Hellerew
Classic pizza joint right in the heart of downtown. Each week, they have unique specials–slice of the week, wing of the week, sandwich of the week etc. A couple of my favorite slice specials were the Fish & Chips slice (yep..catfish & fries perfectly fried on top a bed of cheesy goodness) & the Crab Rangoon slice (a creamy base with wonton strips and a drizzle of sweet Thai chili sauce. The peach wings were good as well. This place is full of history!
… moreKristopher Nelson
From the dough maker, hot line, to amazing bar staff. This family owned and run pizzeria is the spot to be. Not to mention they have great happy hour deals.
We will definitely come back to hit the late night window to grab a slice. Highly recommended to anyone who wants great amazing Za!
… moreMeli J (MeliJ)
I remembered loving this place when I was in college so I took my kids. Wait staff was aloof to slightly rude. Pizza was burnt. Vibes were weird so thank God we got the burnt pizzas to go. I’ve never seen my kids not finish a pizza. Two pizzas for 50 bucks they should be amazing. I’m giving two stars because maybe it’s still amazing when you are in college and “belong”
… moreElvira Gutierrez
I’ve eaten here several times and always enjoy it. The pizza is very good especially their Supreme which I definitely recommend. Their smoked wings are also very delicious, I recommend coming in on Wednesdays for $1 wings which is a pretty good deal here in town.
The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming and the people working there are always friendly. It’s a comfortable place to sit and enjoy a nice meal.
I’m always happy to come back and would recommend it to others.
… moreKorbin Weese
Our server was great and the atmosphere was welcoming. Growing up, I always ordered the cheese sticks (bread), so I was excited to get them again this visit. Unfortunately, they’re not the same anymore. I understand there are new owners, but the pizza and cheese sticks are nothing like they used to be. The cheese sticks were thin and greasy. I’d recommend bringing back the original recipe from the previous owners — I think business would really take off if you did.
… moreElle Lorenz
First time trying out this place and it’s definitely a place I will come back. Our order was Fried Mushrooms, Fried Pickles, Buffalo Wings and a Supreme Pizza. All food was hot, juicy and full of flavor. The pizza taste homemade not factory made, the pickles were crunchy on the outside but juicy on the inside, the wings were big, juicy and the sauce was to the point and finally the mushrooms were crunchy and juicy. The service was great our server was courteous and the place is big enough with a good atmosphere.
… moreRich Martinez
Came in after years of living up north! Mikaela was very kind and generous with her time! Thank you for my visit!
… moreKelsie
BEST pizza in san marcos! From the kitchen to front of house. The food was made with love and the customer service is the best. The two cooks in the kitchen made my food i think their names were seth and ricardo and it was PERFECT. Mikaela helped me and was so sweet and kind. Made me feel so welcomed. 12/10 recommend!!!
… more