Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Fratelli’s Neighborhood Italian – CLOSED, 506 W Pine St, Baraboo …
Get more information for Fratelli’s Neighborhood Italian in Baraboo, WI. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Fratelli’s Italian Restaurant (@fratellis_italian) – Instagram
776 followers · 96 posts · Pizza, pasta, sandwiches, salads, bar.
Fratelli’s Neighborhood Italian Restaurant (@eatatfratellis) / Posts / X
Fratelli’s Neighborhood Italian Restaurant. eatatfratellis. Location: Baraboo, WI. Website: http://www.myfratellis.com. Joined: Jun 14, 2016. 100Posts. 1330 …
Reviews
Laura A
The service, decor, and food was SPOT ON! The portions are very generous, the Gorgonzola Chicken and Ultimate Fettuccine were both amazing.
… morePatriot Kieler
Excellent family friendly Italian restaurant. Great service, with great food.
… moreJosh E
Food was very good! Staff was super cool! I would’ve liked more check-ins for new drinks or refills though. But overall, I loved it!!!! Oh yea, and the prices are not insane for a pleasant meal!
… moreMal ix (malix12700)
Raw food, bread at every other table except ours, and we had to ask for kids menus even though the were 2 children at the table under 9! Sad to say bit this was by far the worst experience I’ve had in a restaurant in a very long time.
We ordered a meatball sub and the meatballs were pink in the middle. To their credit they made a fresh one when it was sent back, but these meatballs were also pink. The chicken sandwich ordered was also a disappointment because the tomato was bigger than the chicken! The spaghetti my son ordered for his kids meal was overcooked and mushy. After the second meatball sub was sent back we were asked if we’d just prefer something else. A BLT was ordered, yet what came back had bacon (?) on it easily twice as thick as the thickest cut bacon I’ve even seen. It was like a cut of pork with lettuce and tomato. About the only thing that was well cooked, seasoned properly, and enjoyed by everyone was the french fries. That’s rather unfortunately for an Italian restaurant.
The service was lackluster. Other than a couple times through the whole meal we had to get attention of a staff member to get assistance with what had been going on. And we never got our bread even though the tables there before and after us had received theirs.
I can honestly say we won’t be there again. And as sad as it will be to see another business fail in that building, I can’t see them lasting that long at this rate.
… moreWe ordered a meatball sub and the meatballs were pink in the middle. To their credit they made a fresh one when it was sent back, but these meatballs were also pink. The chicken sandwich ordered was also a disappointment because the tomato was bigger than the chicken! The spaghetti my son ordered for his kids meal was overcooked and mushy. After the second meatball sub was sent back we were asked if we’d just prefer something else. A BLT was ordered, yet what came back had bacon (?) on it easily twice as thick as the thickest cut bacon I’ve even seen. It was like a cut of pork with lettuce and tomato. About the only thing that was well cooked, seasoned properly, and enjoyed by everyone was the french fries. That’s rather unfortunately for an Italian restaurant.
The service was lackluster. Other than a couple times through the whole meal we had to get attention of a staff member to get assistance with what had been going on. And we never got our bread even though the tables there before and after us had received theirs.
I can honestly say we won’t be there again. And as sad as it will be to see another business fail in that building, I can’t see them lasting that long at this rate.
Lauryn K
Don’t order the Shrimp Scampi unless all you want for $15 is 11 small, over-cooked shrimp. There are no sides with it, not even a bread stick (unless my takeout order was packed incorrectly)! It was the saddest looking takeout container ever. I would have let it slide if they were delicious, but nope, just subpar and slightly fishy-tasting. I had the Ultimate Fettucine last week and it was pretty good (with huge portions), so I was hopeful for this new place… now, I’m not so sure. Maybe this is the ONE dish to avoid and the rest are great, but this experience has put me off.
… moreTimothy Boyce
Food is very good, alittle pricey. Sam the manager is awesome, very friendly and good at what she does.
I had the italian beef sandwich, price too high for the size, especially when you can go to the dells get a bigger sandwich at lower price. Otherwise food and service was good.
… moreI had the italian beef sandwich, price too high for the size, especially when you can go to the dells get a bigger sandwich at lower price. Otherwise food and service was good.
Ellen Lala
Our waitress was wonderful. I had spaghetti and meatballs. No flavor , no garlic . No oregano..very bland . The bread that was supposed to be garlic bread . No garlic flavor at all and no warm. My husband had Gnocci Seratino . No flavor over done . Cheese and parsely on top. This is not Italian at all . Taste like rago from jar and paste…we will not be back. Very disappointed!!!!!
… morePaige Lewison
The food was so good. There was huge portions and I wish I could eat more!! Delicious marinara and vinnagrette salad!! Would definatly recommend this restaurant to anyone that loves all things Italian!!! Great service and food, you have to come to this restaurant!!
… moreCatherine Riley
This was our 1st night at Fratelli’s in Baraboo.
We will be back, we had a great waitress, her name was Kitty.
I had spaghetti and meatballs and my husband had the Ultimate chicken fettuccine. …both exellent! !
The complimentary bread was so fresh & warm and we probably could have eaten more, but we filled up fast!! The portions are large, bring your appetite.
We will be back!! Please don’t change anything!!
Welcome to Baraboo…we don’t have to go to Olive Garden. (Actually this was better!)
… moreWe will be back, we had a great waitress, her name was Kitty.
I had spaghetti and meatballs and my husband had the Ultimate chicken fettuccine. …both exellent! !
The complimentary bread was so fresh & warm and we probably could have eaten more, but we filled up fast!! The portions are large, bring your appetite.
We will be back!! Please don’t change anything!!
Welcome to Baraboo…we don’t have to go to Olive Garden. (Actually this was better!)
Sheliah Altendorf Holloway
My husband and I were visiting today . We decided to ride and see the town. After hours of driving. I googled Italian good for Baraboo. And thus, we made it here AWESOME FOOD. HUMONGOUS HELPINGS. GREATER HOSPITALITY!!!!!! WORTH EVERY DIME WILL DEFINITELY TRAVEL BACK FOR ANOTHER VISIT SHELLY IS SO WONDERFUL!!!!!!! FANTASTIC WAITRESS SHELLY IS THE BEST WAITRESS!!!!!! FANTASTIC PERSONALITY
… more