Eric Rowles
Chicken francese and stuffed shells the food was fantastic service was great or waitress was awesome her name was Tammy she is awesome. Great atmosphere great prices highly recommend. We came in late and they still told us to sit down and have a great meal just like an Italian family always does
… moreJack Redding
Was traveling for business and staying at Courtyard and didn’t want to eat at a chain. Was pleasantly surprised by friendly staff greeted me when I walked in. (Felt like they actually wanted my business!). Caitlyn was great and guided me through the menu. Got the Shrimp Parm which was a very generous and delicious portion and came with warm bread and salad. I’ll be back next time traveling through Kingston.
… moreSai
I recently dined at A Slice of Italy in New York, and I can honestly say it was the best pepperoni pizza I’ve ever had! The crust was perfectly crisp yet chewy, and the pepperoni was flavorful with just the right amount of spice. Each bite was a perfect combination of rich tomato sauce, melted cheese, and that iconic pepperoni taste.
But it wasn’t just the pizza that made the experience memorable—the service was outstanding. A sweet lady took care of everything with such warmth and attentiveness, ensuring we had everything we needed. Her friendly demeanor and genuine care for customers made the meal even more enjoyable.
If you’re looking for incredible pizza and top-notch service, A Slice of Italy is a must-visit. I’ll definitely be back to try more!
… moreKrista Barringer
It was amazing. We went for our anniversary dinner after reading an article that had them in the top 10 upstate NY Italian restaurants. Knowing upstate is a large area, I was thrilled they were in our backyard. They did not disappoint. The eggplant melted in the mouth, the portions were generous, prices reasonable and the staff were wonderful. An enjoyable experience all around and we look forward to taking the family back to our new “favorite”.
… moreJames Harrington
I was back in Ny for a funeral. Stopped by there for dinner. My wife pointed out that it’s going to be good food as it’s full of local people. The absolute best I’ve ever had. And as I sipped my beer from my ny Giants pint glassI explained to my waitress that I live in MA. When we left she bagged up my glass for the road. I’ll never forget:)
… moreFred
Food was great. Service was awesome. Caitlynn was great!!! Staff was friendly great atmosphere. No waiting around for food. The desert is amazing. The peanut butter mouse is top notch. Looking forward to going back!!!
… moreDeidra Elston
One of our favs! Great prices, FRESH food, excellent pizza and service is always top notch! Can’t recommend enough
… moreTony Monaco
Tammy is a National Treasure and all who have the pleasure of sitting in her section should be required to write a poem on the spot to pay homage to her.
Since it’s my suggestion, I’m not going to write one but am eagerly awaiting your feeble responses to try and match how awesome she is. You will fail to live up to her wittiness and you will like it! Or else… honestly, I’m terrified of her all at the same time!
… moreΔιονύσης Κατσουλέας
We really liked the atmosphere! Great delicious pizza and friendly people!
… moreSteve McDaniel
Wow! Another great find. Recommended by our hotel and right next door. Super friendly service as we were seated right away. Ordered a bottle of wine and settled in. Loosen your belt cause this was a good one. The salad was delish and the bread fresh and nice crunchy crust. Ravioli was wonderful and marinara sauce perfect accompaniment. The star of this show was the veal parmigiana. Cut it with a fork and melted in your mouth. Penne pasta was perfect Aldente and marinara sauce here as well. So much food. Walked out stuffed. Prices very reasonable. Get your Italian fix right here. #stevensleavin.
… more