Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Signature pizzas, hearty pasta dishes & subs served in a down-to-earth dine-in space.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 558 W Main St, Cobleskill, NY 12043
Phone: (518) 234-8518
Website: http://www.pizzashackcobleskill.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza Shack – A taste of Italy at its best
Located in downtown Cobleskill since 1981. Family owned and operated. A taste of Italy at its best. VIEW MENU. Located in downtown Cobleskill since 1981.
Pizza Shack of Cobleskill
A taste of Italy at its best. Address: 558 Main Street, Cobleskill, NY 12043. Phone: (518)234-8518. Copyright 2021 – Pizza Shack, all rights reserved.
Pizza Shack, Cobleskill – Facebook
Pizza Shack, Cobleskill, Cobleskill. 4328 likes · 25 talking about this. family owned and operated pizzeria Italian restaurant.
Reviews
Kelly Crast
Ordered 3 pizzas, wings, and garlic knots. One of the pizzas and the garlic knots were both horribly burnt on the bottom. Tasted like nothing but burnt. Very unfortunate since it was for a birthday party.
… moreMarsha Graham
Ordered this for lunch today on 12/9/2025
Got it delivered, this is what I received horrible, and when I called they did not apologize, all that was said was do you want credit or another one. Very poor service
… moreGot it delivered, this is what I received horrible, and when I called they did not apologize, all that was said was do you want credit or another one. Very poor service
Cody Zink
Bought the 24 cut, which came as two Sicilian 12 cuts. Crust was tough to bite through, mostly bread with little sauce and some slices had almost no cheese. Much more crust than I would have liked due to the insufficient covering, just too dry. Veggie toppings were almost not cooked and still raw and crunchy. I’ve had much better from this place, but today they really disappointed.
… moreSabrinna Utter
Like walking into a resturant owned by your family. They tossed the pizza for my boy and let him watch them make it. So good!!
… moreTrinity Appell
My boyfriend and I have been wanting to try this place out for a while and we’re happy we finally did. Everyone was super nice and the pizza tasted amazing and hot. I definitely recommend the bang bang chicken pizza and the white veggie pizza! Great place for college kids to sit and relax while getting something to eat or if you’re just out and about in town!
… morekuldeep kumar
It was okay. We got the garlic bread and Al’s pie with buffalo chicken. The pizza was good. The garlic bread was not great. Service was quick and staff did a good job.
… moreJoseph Palmatier
Well tried to order again from pizza shack guess this will be the last time pizza was ok I guess but the pepperoni rolls were burnt and hard as a rock and the wings had a weird taste to them not sure what its from but come on pizza shack what is going on. Something needs to be looked at this is numerous times now and and very little being done to make it right.
… moreEli Smith
I’ve eaten in the restaurant and ordered delivery!! Either way the staff are super friendly and good at their jobs, and the food (especially the pizza) is always delicious and cooked to perfection! if you ask for certain adjustments like I do with having my garlic knots slightly undercooked, they are willing and happy to oblige! The wait time may be a bit long for delivery dependant on where you live and how much you order, but is not usually longer than a 45 minute wait, and is a wait well worth it!
… moreEfrain Torres
Had a great family experience dinning here at this spot. We had been visiting the Howe Taverns nearby and choose this Pizza stop to eat after our visit. The pepperoni pizza was great and I would recommend to others who are visiting this area.
… moreGeovanny
Burgers are fantastic and a great deal! There’s plenty of seating available.
… more