Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Mill Creek is a favorite neighborhood restaurant in Bayville, NY, offering a relaxed yet casually elegant setting for seasonally inspired American cuisine. Our dinner menu features fresh, flavorful dishes and daily specials, enjoyed in both the dining room and bar. Our bar offers an exceptional wine list, local craft and micro-brews, and a diverse selection of handcrafted specialty cocktails. Mill Creek specializes in catering and private events, including baby and bridal showers, baptisms, rehearsal dinners, family celebrations, and group dining. With dedicated private dining and event spaces, warm hospitality, and great value, we look forward to welcoming you soon.
Neighborhood go-to with a full bar & warm dining room serving seafood, steaks & other American eats.
Hours
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Friday | 4:30–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4:30–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 275 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709
Phone: (516) 628-2000
Website: http://www.millcreekny.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mill Creek – Bayville, NY
… and event spaces available. Mill Creek Tavern is renowned for its warm hospitality and great value. We can’t wait to see you soon! Cheers, Rich!
Mill Creek Tavern | Bayville NY – Facebook
Mill Creek Tavern ; Details. . 96% recommend (353 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 275 Bayville Avenue, Bayville, NY, United States, 11709 ; Links. .
Mill Creek Tavern (@millcreek.ny) • Instagram photos and videos
American Cuisine. Wine, Local Micro Brews, Handcrafted Cocktails. The heart of Bayville. Email us to inquire about catering!
Last Updates
Reviews
Angelina Curcio
Delicious celebration back in June but just got around to my review. Such a great deal on a delicious meal. The pork chops were so moist and tender and full of flavor. The lobster had a surprising white butter garlic sauce, I just wish I had asked for some Linguine to soak up the flavor.
… moreDanielle DeSanno
I love the relaxing vibe at Mill Creek. Perfect spot for a comfort meal and good drinks. Their food is amazing (Mac and cheese is incredible) and the service is even better. Kathy is the absolute best! Girls night isn’t the same when she’s not there.
… moreChristopher Koenig
Had the weekday Price fixed meal, starting with a buffalo spring roll (sorry forgot to take a pic) Yum! Then to this Lemon Sole Oreganata. The full price menu item is a bit larger, but the slightly smaller price fix plate doesn’t take away from the flavor of the dish. Just don’t expect take home leftovers. Well worth the price.
… moreA Hart
We are regulars so obviously we love it. From the Covid days of curb-side meal pick up to the amazing happy hour deals or from the mid week awesome prix fixe menus to the delicious weekend specials you are going to eat and drink well. The menu is expansive and the portions are take-home-tomorrow’s-lunch. Don’t skip the mussels or the schnitzel! Love the Mill Creek❤️
… moreTatiana Panova
We decided to celebrate March 8th in that place. We came about noon, and it’s been pretty empty. You can tell it’s a local restaurant . The food was pretty decent, and I drank champagne, so it’s obvious the bartender wasn’t worked so hard on drinks. Atmosphere been very relaxing. The only things I don’t like are a service. It was ok,but it looks like workers don’t wanna be there. Maybe because they are tired. But I will definitely stop by.
… moreJoelle Soliman
We love mill creek! The food is delicious- especially the cozy dishes they serve when you need some comfort food- short ribs and Shepard’s pie are some of my favorites. The service is excellent and the staff is great! Shout out to Jean and Brandon!
… moreKristyn Buffa
I received a gift card Mill Creek Tavern in Bayville recently so Saturday we checked it out. We arrived right at 5:00 which I think was the move because by the time we left, both sides of the restaurant and the bar were packed.
We shared a fried calamari appetizer (perfect cook)
My husband had Sauerbraten Short Ribs
(Mustard herb späetzle, and braised red cabbage) and I had Chicken Schnitzel with mushroom gravy and a side of creamed spinach.
Not pictured is our delicious tiramisu
I will say our server was just a little…awkward? Nice but odd to interact with whoever, not in an off putting way and was attentive
We can’t wait to go back!
… moreWe shared a fried calamari appetizer (perfect cook)
My husband had Sauerbraten Short Ribs
(Mustard herb späetzle, and braised red cabbage) and I had Chicken Schnitzel with mushroom gravy and a side of creamed spinach.
Not pictured is our delicious tiramisu
I will say our server was just a little…awkward? Nice but odd to interact with whoever, not in an off putting way and was attentive
We can’t wait to go back!
Nicole Cotroneo
I’ve been coming here for 17 years and it is definitely my favorite restaurant of all time. The atmosphere is very nice and the service is so good! All of the servers are very sweet. The food is outstanding, I will forever love it here!
… moreChristine Graziosi
Mill Creek is always our go to place! The food is consistently great, love the atmosphere and Vanessa, Gene and Donna make the experience all that much more enjoyable!! Such a great staple in our town!!
… moreVictoria Ford
Great atmosphere and amazing food! I’ve been coming here many many years and every meal is always spot on delicious. The service is outstanding . Perfect place for a night out.
… more