Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Sun Prairie, WI, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Sun Prairie pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Sun Prairie or stop by 2681 Windsor St for carryout to order the best pizza in Sun Prairie, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2681 Windsor St, Sun Prairie, WI 53590
Phone: (608) 478-0388
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Papa Johns Windsor St – Sun Prairie
Call us for pizza delivery in Sun Prairie or stop by 2681 Windsor St for carryout to order the best pizza in Sun Prairie, along with breadsticks, wings, and …
Pizza in Sun Prairie, WI | Papa Johns Windsor St
For pizza delivery in Sun Prairie, call us at (608) 478-0388 to order, or stop by 2681 Windsor St in Sun Prairie, WI for carryout.
papa johns stores in sun prairie, wi
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Last Updates
Reviews
Kelsey Richmond
We paid $100 for 2 pizzas, 2 wings and garlic knots. We didn’t get the correct pizzas. We ordered a large stuffed crust and got plain crust and hardly any cheese on one pizza. We ordered a garlic Alfredo pizza with extra cheese and it is evident we did not get that. The garlic knots are very burnt. The wings barely had sauce. Would not recommend wasting money to go to this Papa John’s. Would recommend driving further for Pizza Hut or Domino’s if ordering from this style pizza chain.
… moreNicole Bradley
We order from here every week and I’m getting real sick of them using door dash. They make multiple stops along the way and we get our 40 bucks worth of pizza an hour later cold. From now on I’m ordering dominoes and Pizza Hut they have their own drivers who get it to me right out of the oven. The only reason I order here is because my husband likes it.
… moreShadow VirusCybug
The pizza was good, but instead of ordering through DoorDash, I decided to order pickup instead, so my mom and I drove to the location, only to find out that the guy had given my pizza to a Dasher when he entered my order information, I told him “I didn’t order a Dasher? I ordered pick up.” Thankfully, he offered to make my pizza, which took 15 minutes. I think I saw a review about employees being suspicious of DoorDashers, I’m not sure whether someone is going as a Dasher and stealing orders. I hope they fixed the issue by now.
… moreCristin Colvin
We have ordered from Papa John’s a lot and this is not what I would call acceptable but any stretch. The pizza on the left had barely any toppings and the one on the right is it extremely over done. I called and spoke to a manager, who informed me they “looked great” coming out of the oven. He also said “I don’t know what you want me to do.” I was finally offered a free 12 in pizza – with the instructions that next time I call, I should “just tell them my name and they’ll give me a free pizza next time. I only have to provide today’s date, my name, and the time I called today “. So that seems like it definitely won’t be happening. Incredibly disappointed and won’t be back.
… moreAlex B
I wish I could give 0 stars. I reluctantly gave this store one last shot. However, never again will I go back. Does leadership here even care about the product that leaves the door. I’ve received a pizza made completely wrong previously. I’ve received garlic breadsticks burnt. I’ve received garlic breasticks with no sauce. This most recent order consisted of 2 orders of garlic breadsticks, and they are sad. Clearly, quality is not a concern of this location. Go spend your money somewhere where they will actually put some care in the food they put out.
… moreAaron Horton
As a previous review stated, the corporate start up crew has left the building. The first month the place was open, the food was great. From there, each experience steadily got worse. From missing sauces to burnt food, I have experienced it at this location. Today, it was a blatant disregard for instruction. I order light sauce and get a sauce pie that doesn’t even have cheese on the whole pizza. I just honestly feel bad feeding my kids this crap.
… moreBen B
If I could give zero stars I would. Those in charge clearly don’t care since no one is responding to reviews. Waiting over an hour for our order just to find out that it wasn’t even started after the planned delivery time. Tried to call the store, no one answered (shocking). Then the order screen switched over to door dash and delivery time showed it would be another hour before it would be delivered. I feel sorry for the Door dash driver that sat and waited there while the staff there had to finish our order (20 minutes). Ultimately the order showed up a half hour from the original promised time. All the while we have hangry kids wanting to have pizza with our Friday night movie after a long and stressful week. Based on other reviews it’s clear they have a staffing issue.
… moreRuby Rose
New Years Day. One employee working. One. Pizza was going to take 30 minutes longer than the app estimated. No communication; no updates. Clearly no care for their employees or customers. Needs new management.
… moreForrest Hess
Walked in for a pickup order and was ignored by five employees standing near the register. John, who seemed to be the manager, fiddled with the register for five minutes before everyone scattered. It took 10 minutes just to get my already-finished order—and the food was mediocre at best. I use to love ordering from here..
… moreClayton Harper
Too much sauce at this location. I think they should ask customers light or heavy sauce and I don’t think I have had any good pizza at this location
… more