Address and Contact Information
Address: 190 Montauk Hwy, Speonk, NY 11972
Phone: (631) 801-6600
Website: https://maryspizzaandpasta.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home-Speonk – MarysPizza
WELCOME TO MARY’S PIZZA & PASTA!
Welcome to Mary’s Pizza and Pasta – MarysPizza
FARMINGDALE, NY 11735 516.586.5917. ENTER FARMINGDALE. SPEONK. 190 MONTAUK HIGHWAY SPEONK, NY 11972 631.801.6600. ENTER SPEONK. ISLIP TERRACE; FARMINGDALE …
Menus – Speonk – MarysPizza
Contact Us Today! If you are interested in Mary’s Pizza and Pasta and have a question or comment, and we will try to answer it as quickly as …
Reviews
Albert Milite
This place is FABULOUS! The sign outside says “Pizza-Bar-Grill” – 3 of my FAVORITE words on the SAME sign! I pass it all the time and always wanted to stop in. Finally did today and oh so glad I did. What an amazing menu! The food, drinks, staff, vibe – everything was just terrific! If you haven’t tried this place you MUST! I’ll be back again and again!
… moreJoseph Kopel
Delicious. Chicken Capri and Chicken Cordon Bleu were phenomenal. Huge portion sizes. Rice balls and meatballs were also out of this world. Desserts were tops too. Tried the carrot cake, tiramisu and chocolate cake all delish. Definitely give them a try
… moreMala Sharma
A Five-Star Feast with LICOA – Unforgettable Dining Experience!
Visited Mary’s Pizza & Pasta in Speonk on June 1, 2025 with the LICOA club, and the entire experience was outstanding — easily one of the best group dining experiences we’ve had on Long Island.
From start to finish, the food was phenomenal. We kicked things off with a classic Caesar salad — crisp romaine, bold dressing, and fresh parmesan. The pizza was perfection: crispy crust, rich sauce, and melty cheese that had everyone going back for seconds.
Entrees were a true highlight. The Chicken Francese was tender and lemony, just the right balance of richness and acidity. The Sausage & Peppers were full of flavor, hearty and satisfying. The Eggplant Rollatini melted in your mouth — creamy ricotta inside and a light, savory marinara outside. The salmon was beautifully cooked, flaky and fresh, paired perfectly with the sautéed vegetables, which were vibrant and full of natural flavor.
We ended on a high note with strong, delicious coffee and cannoli filled with chocolate chip-studded cream and topped with chocolate sprinkles — the perfect sweet finish.
The staff was attentive and incredibly accommodating for our large group, and the warm, welcoming atmosphere made us feel right at home. Mary’s is the kind of place that reminds you why you love Italian food.
Highly recommended — we’ll definitely be back!
— LICOA Club Member & 2nd Photographer, June 2025
P L
All the Italian favorites served in generous portions by an amazing staff! Definitely recommend!
… moreDiana G
Our waitress Ashley was fabulous and made our night! Food was delicious! The food was delicious and very generous portions. The drinks were terrific! Overall wonderful experience! We spend Yeah Per person
… moreElizabeth Stelling
They were very busy but we were seated right away. I had the eggplant parmigiana while my friend had spaghetti and meatballs. Both were delicious. I groaned inwardly when my friend ordered the meatballs because she’s picky about meatballs but she loved them so that’s a rave! The garlic bread wedges were yummy too. Drinks were 14 and 15 dollars.
… moreJay Sar
Mary’s is a great little gem in Speonk. Food is always good and pizza is amazing. The place gets crowded and parking can be a bit of a pain but that is really the only downside. The owners are great and always giving back to community. It is a welcome addition to the area.
… moreDaniel Grant
Excellent food,large portions, priced well and service was great. Will absolutely be returning for another meal soon!
… moreThomas Davis
We had a great experience at Mary’s. The waiter allowed us to put in the kids’ orders right away. The calamari was good as well as the chicken Capri and the special lobster risotto. Portions are on the large side.
… moreShawn Noonan
My wife and I enjoyed a nice Valentine’s Day dinner here. We had the rice balls and Barada and then split a chicken dish for dinner. Finally finished it off with the carrot cake. The food was very good and the service was excellent. We sat at a high table near the bar and it was a little bit loud but a very good friendly atmosphere
… more