Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Casual NY Style Pizzeria serving Slices, Salads, Pastas, Heros, Wraps, Soups, Oven Baked Dishes, Classic Chicken, Veal, Eggplant & Seafood Dishes, Desserts, and of course a large assortment of hand crafted specialty pies or build your own. Delivery-Take Out-Catering. Beer & Wine Served. Fast and easy to use ONLINE Ordering system for delivery and pick up orders.
Standard Italian eats, bacon-topped pizzas & other specialty pies stand out at this informal eatery.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 17 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy, Commack, NY 11725
Phone: (631) 499-7000
Website: http://marioscommack.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Marios Pizza | Commack
PIZZA. ARTISAN. PASTA DISHES. freshmade to order. salads. HAND CRAFTED. PIZZA … 17 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy Commack, NY 11725. Copyright © 2019 | All rights …
Mario’s Pizzeria of Commack – Facebook
Us pretending like you don’t need a saucy tortellini meal to warm the soul Grab your family, friends, and appetite because we’ve got eating to do …
Mario’s Pizzeria of Commack – Grubhub
Mario’s Pizzeria of Commack (17 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy) is a Pizza restaurant. Q) Is Mario’s Pizzeria of Commack (17 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy) eligible for Grubhub+ …
Reviews
Stephanie
The food is absolutely delicious, and the service is amazing! Daniela at the front is such a doll—so warm and welcoming. Chris was wonderful too! Definitely a place I’ll be coming back to.
… moreAntonioUrbano
Not sure if this Mario’s is a part of the chain, but the pizza and service were both amazing. Walked in shortly before closing hoping something was still available. A gentleman behind the counter happily read off the options still available and prepped my order. I will be returning to this location as I work nearby. Thank you to the staff for being so friendly close to closing time. It’s not unnoticed and it is definitely appreciated
… moreAlexandra Grunin
Mario’s was a great experience today! Delicious food and great service. Daniela Chris and Makaila were very welcoming. The chicken franchise was great! Can’t wait to try the empanada later! Will definitely be back.
… moreJennifer England
This has been the best experience I’ve ever had at a pizzeria on Long Island! From the absolutely delicious grandma pizza I ordered to the warm and friendly staff up front, everything was perfect.
A special shoutout to Daniela, the glowing young lady who took care of me—her kindness and professionalism made the visit even better.
I truly felt welcomed the moment I stepped in, and that warmth carried through the entire experience—from ordering to eating, and even when my plate was picked up as I was leaving. Everything about this visit showed care, consistency, and genuine hospitality.
Can’t wait to come back! ✨
… moreA special shoutout to Daniela, the glowing young lady who took care of me—her kindness and professionalism made the visit even better.
I truly felt welcomed the moment I stepped in, and that warmth carried through the entire experience—from ordering to eating, and even when my plate was picked up as I was leaving. Everything about this visit showed care, consistency, and genuine hospitality.
Can’t wait to come back! ✨
Jannelly Avelaine
Walked in was taken aback by the spacious clean aesthetic of the place. My eyes were drawn to the wide selection of pizza flavor combos. Daniela and Makaila were so patient and super friendly, they helped me choose when I was so undecided. Chris attended our large party of over 15 with so much ease and care. It’s my first time coming and will definitely continue after this. The pizzas were so fresh! I had the tomato balsamic was a 10/10 and each bite had that perfect crunch, IYKYK!
… moreR. McAllister
Literally shocked. Had to run some errands out in Long Island and figured I’d make a quick day trip of it. As a Brooklynite, I’ll be honest I was skeptical about Long Island pizza. But this spot completely surprised me. The slice was perfect & crisp.
The woman behind the counter, with long jet-black hair, was super sweet and attentive. She made sure everything was right and had a really pleasant vibe. Def going back.
… moreThe woman behind the counter, with long jet-black hair, was super sweet and attentive. She made sure everything was right and had a really pleasant vibe. Def going back.
Jonathan Colon
Mario’s Pizza in Commack is top-tier! The food is always incredible — fresh, flavorful, and made with care. The pizza is perfectly cooked, the pasta dishes are delicious, and everything tastes homemade. But what really makes the experience stand out is Daniela’s amazing hosting! She’s warm, welcoming, and always goes above and beyond to make you feel at home. Great food and even better service — can’t ask for more. Highly recommend! ❤️
… moreAdrian Stachura
The staff are cool i like them. I get the too good to go its a gamble though. Sometimes i get lucky other times its depressing. For the times i got crazy amount of food 5/5.
… moreJay Moses
Stopped in this afternoon and was completely turned off by what I saw. The woman behind the counter (dark hair) was literally eating her lunch right in front of me while helping customers—totally unprofessional. Then the guy cutting my pizzas had a beard and was wearing a dirty blue sweatshirt that was dragging into the pizza. Absolutely unacceptable. At least the main pizza guy was protecting his face with a mask as I noticed he had a beard so props to him for wearing appropriate garments and face coverings. I would be embarrassed if I were that nice man to work with complete disgusting people
Do they not have uniforms here? Between her eating at the counter and him looking like he just came from a construction site, it’s a total health concern. I already reported this to Suffolk County Health because this is not okay. There should NOT be sweatshirts in any restaurant and the health department was told this today. Wear clean uniforms and look professional if you’re handling food. I won’t be coming back, and I hope they get inspected ASAP.
… moreDo they not have uniforms here? Between her eating at the counter and him looking like he just came from a construction site, it’s a total health concern. I already reported this to Suffolk County Health because this is not okay. There should NOT be sweatshirts in any restaurant and the health department was told this today. Wear clean uniforms and look professional if you’re handling food. I won’t be coming back, and I hope they get inspected ASAP.
Ava-Dawn Gabbidon
Love this place! I started coming here regularly at the beginning of the year with a group for meetings, and every single time the food and service have been outstanding. The staff is warm and friendly, the atmosphere is inviting, and it’s clear the owner truly cares about creating a great experience. It’s become a place that feels like part of the community. I’ve only ever seen professionalism and genuine hospitality—highly recommend!
… more