Katrina Sherlock
We spent the weekend visiting family in NY and this place was recommended by our hotel. We were not disappointed! Food was amazing! We ended up ordering two nights in a row! We had the Philly sub, spaghetti, chicken parm, garlic bread, Mac and cheese, salads and a few other things. The salads were fresh the garlic bread was delicious. Definitely recommend!
… moreJJ
Great pizza, nice service and dining room. Highly recommended. My 1st time here.
… moreTrenton Green
Very nice place food was very good all of the food was very good the service was great and the chicken tender subs are not very good.
… moreBri Warren
Visiting from Florida and don’t get a chance to have pizza like I used to as a kid. This place hit the boxes for me: crispy thin crust, flavorful sauce, nice cheese blend. Chicken wing pizza was 10/10. Salad was good, generous portion with toppings enough to share. Price is worth it for the quality you get. Sad to see the other reviews as I was hesitant but now glad with our decision kids were happy too.
… moreAdam Schuster
My friend says, “Good, very good!” With a mouth full of pizza
… moreKasi
Garlic bread was undercooked.
We ordered hot, extra crispy chicken wings. The wings were very small and not crispy.
We also ordered Stromboli, it was essentially a pizza just folded in half. It was just okay. Delivery was good. We heard it was under new ownership, unfortunately our food was not great. So disappointed.
… moreRobert Mcevoy
I had my doubts is ordered 2 salads with chicken supposed to get.Ranch must not have been included pretty surprised for $30 and change. That won’t happen again
… moreTenting Fulltime
Listen, I’m a pizza snob no question about it, I come from a place where good pizza is readily available….that being said I’d never want to get on google and slam the only decent pizza place in town. New owner new management and I know there’s gonna be growing pains while trying to maximize/optimize profits…the pizza is still good for the area, no question about that…but no self respecting pizza shop would ever serve wings in plastic containers! Forget the fact that you removed the option to order all “flats” or “drumsticks” because that’s unheard of and was just a bonus of the old owner but for what you saved in cost switching to plastic you lose so much in quality. No one wants to eat a soggy chicken wing, and at todays prices your customers are on the fence about even ordering the wings…so when we do it, would be nice to get something that’s not soggy and humidified by a plastic, condensation catching container. Good luck on the venture but please consider the old standard paper/corrugated wing containers. Again, this pizza is still good for Hornell, but at this point I wouldn’t order wings again if they are gonna be soggy and wet because they are boxed in a plastic humidity dome.
… moretonya helles
The staff are always friendly and willing to help no matter what the situation. They also have the best pizza in town.
… moreCalvin Livesay
This is a great pizzeria! I got the stuffed pizza, not stuffed crust. This thing is huge, tasty, and worth the price. I’ll recommend it to anyone visiting Hornell, NY. If you need to feed a few people or have some for later Stop Here First. I guess you can say it is the reviewers choice.
… more