D. Waylon Walton
If you are looking for excellent seafood, this is a must stop on your 30A experience! Grouper was perfect and the hush puppies were fantastic!
… moreJudy Wittenberg
Enjoyed a wonderful dinner …the food was delicious and we were well taken care of. Crab legs cooked perfectly and the key lime pie was amazing. I highly recommend if you are liking for a casual plane to enjoy great seafood .
… moreMegan
While I recommend that you try Reel ‘Em In Fresh Seafood Market for good seafood and friendly service, our family and friends will likely go elsewhere the next time we visit the area. Overall, the seafood tasted fresh and was cooked and seasoned to perfection – the main reason why you go to a seafood market! However, the sides tasted greasy and soggy. We also viewed Reel ‘Em In as slightly overpriced and overrated compared to other markets in the area. Plus, with only two employees working at the time of our order pickup, the wait far exceeded what we were told.
We enjoyed the seafood but, everything else about our experience left us feeling underwhelmed.
Edit: I gave consistent and honest reviews for this business on Google and Yelp. Unfortunately, I received replies from the owner that I view as a bit rude (especially the reply on Yelp). I stand by my review. While I still encourage people to try this place, my family and friends will not go back after this exchange. I do wish this small business well, however.
FINAL UPDATE: After direct communication with the owner on Yelp, I understand how a 3 star review feels too harsh. The seafood tasted good and, while I appreciate the offer of a free meal, I intend to pay full price when I try them again next time we visit. I don’t want to add to the struggle of a small family-owned business. Thank you to the owner for reaching out to me directly.
… moreBrad Kasprzak
What a great experience! Down in FL with the midwestern family on Spring Break and this was so easy to prepare. Really fun to dump out the buckets on the counter and see all the wonderful seafood. Price was very reasonable for the amount of food. The 2 buckets easily fed 7 adults with food left over (We did finish the crab right away! But some shrimp and potatoes were left for lunch the next day). Highly recommend this if your down on vacation and looking for some Seafood at home but not in the mood to eat out.
… moreau frankie
Happened upon this place “google” searching and it did not disappoint! Caelyn was stellar at getting our order ready earlier than we thought. Within walking distance of Hidden Beach Villas. Got the 12 Lb Shrimp W Corn And Potatoes x 2 for only $40 and it was awesome. Portions were fantastic, seasoning Goldilocks just right. The $10 cocktail sauce was fine but I wish I had gotten some at Publix and just spent more on their offerings. Yes they defer the 3% credit card fee to you but so does most of the beach. (We’re only talking a buck fifty) We have found our new and only steamed place when we visit Santa Rosa ️. Just writing this makes me yearn to try the cakes.
… moreCraig Lodl
Amazing!!! From the start the customer service, quality of food, presentation, to ease of cooking, so amazing. They provided everything, our seafood steam was amazing. We had rented a house and each family took a night to prepare a meal. With the help of Reel Em In, we placed all our items in the provided bucket which went directly on stove to steam and contain everything. We place a 12oz beer and a cup of water in the bottom with provided spices, how simple and amazing. Can’t thank the team enough as of our family loved the dinner!
… moreDavid
If you want fresh seafood to cook in your home or rental, this is the place! I got The Alys steamer pot and although it says it feeds 2-3, it can definitely feed more. The pot I got came with shrimp, crab legs, scallops, AND huge lobster tails! Yeah, you have to cook it yourself but all the seasoning and sauces are provided so all you really do is take out of the bags, add water, and boil. The seafood is very fresh and delicious, same with the butter and even the provided cocktail sauce. For the amount of seafood you get, this is a really good value – less than half what you would spend at a restaurant.
… moreDan Stewart
Get the seafood steamer pot, it was amazing. We ate on it for 2 days and it was even better as leftovers. Staff was helpful and friendly.
… moreCécile Baudry
From service to food, it was excellent. Prices are really good for the quality you get, so flavourful and fresh. I came back for more the day after I tried it. I recommend highly!
… moreKinsey Greene
Food was excellent! The lady who served us was super nice and helpful. We ordered the Snow Crab and Shrimp boil which came with lots of potatoes and corn. Everything was cooked to perfection and perfectly seasoned. My mom had the blackened grouper meal which was delicious! 10/10 highly recommend.
… more