Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
The Whistle Stop Pub is a local favorite offering a blend of pub classics and delicious pizza. This family-owned establishment is your go-to destination for food and drinks, day or night. As the final kitchen and bar open late on Upper Matecumbe, we’re the perfect spot to cap off your evening. Enjoy a relaxed, friendly atmosphere where great food and good company come together. In addition to our dine-in options we also offer a full liquor store as well as an ATM for your convenience.
Basic pub grub & libations are served in relaxed environs with pool tables & TVs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 82685 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Phone: (305) 664-0094
Website: https://whistlestopislamorada.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Whistle Stop | Islamorada FL – Facebook
Whistle Stop, Islamorada. 4060 likes · 35 talking about this · 11685 were here. Whistle Stop Bar and Grill Great Local Spot With Great Food Under new…
The Whistle Stop Pub (Islamorada, FL) presented by BODYARMOR
Dave tries the local pizza place in his new hometown with a bathroom he can’t quite figure out. Download The One Bite App to see more and …
The Whistle Stop Pub | Florida Keys & Key West
Whistle Stop in Islamorada offers classic American comfort food, cold drinks, and a laid-back Keys atmosphere perfect for locals and visitors alike.
Reviews
Jean Bell
We visited the Whistle Stop today after watching Bloodline, which was filmed in the Keys. It was an incredible experience! Lauren, the bartender, and a gentleman who handled the beer ordering (I never caught his name) were fantastic. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, making me feel like I had walked into my neighborhood bar and met up with old friends. The service was great, and the stories shared by the staff were entertaining. We’re definitely planning to return for food in addition to beer next time!
… moreMichael Wisniewski
The Whistle Stop in Islamorada is an absolute gem! A true hole-in-the-wall bar with unbeatable vibes and some of the best pizza I’ve ever had, crispy, flavorful, and unforgettable. The staff is friendly, the atmosphere is laid-back, and it feels like a local secret you’re lucky to find. Perfect stop in the Keys, can’t wait to come back for more!
… moreRandy Kruse
Your local pub and grub with some of the best pizza on the island. Everytime I visit the keys we stop by the whistle stop for a pizza and its great Everytime. It is a local bar so you might run into some island life or things we just dont see in the north. There’s a jukebox and a few pool tables and the liquor store is right next door. Don’t sit in front of the PA speakers it can get loud.
… moreRebecca Linden
Very busy weekend night and they were packed but ended up getting 2 bar seats and a bit loud in there but great music on the juke box and bartenders did their best and soe of the best fish dip ever and the pizza was great!! Definitely be back!!
… moreCarla Stoica
Great pub in Islamorada.
They’ve got 3 pool tables which were in pretty good shape.
We didn’t eat there but we saw others getting food and all looked quite yummy.
Great selection of drinks and even have a juke box which was a nice addition.
Bartenders are friendly and helpful.
Many tvs to watch the news or sport channels.
Highly recommend.
… moreThey’ve got 3 pool tables which were in pretty good shape.
We didn’t eat there but we saw others getting food and all looked quite yummy.
Great selection of drinks and even have a juke box which was a nice addition.
Bartenders are friendly and helpful.
Many tvs to watch the news or sport channels.
Highly recommend.
Kim Darrah
Small unpretentious bar with great pizza and nice people. Usually have the regular double pepperoni round but today tried the Chicago. First time I could only eat 2 pieces! Will order again… Hard not to get the pizza, so on Taco Tuesday we tried beef tacos shown – great! My husband then ordered one Tuna Taco to top off his tank and said that was the best taco he ever had. I tried the cheeseburger which was cooked perfect as I requested and was also good.
They also have a dart board, pool tables, and plenty of TVs for sports. Very nice bartenders!
… moreThey also have a dart board, pool tables, and plenty of TVs for sports. Very nice bartenders!
Angie Junea
So I was down visiting family and one of them suggested the whistle stop. When we walked in we were greeted by two bartenders that quickly made some of the best Long Island ice tea’s. They quickly took our food order of a lrg supreme pizza no Italian sausage and an order of wings garlic parm. We had a couple shots while we waited we chatted with the bars patrons who suggested that the had the best pizza which was not a lie. We still had to send it back because the vegetables were under cooked but they had no complaints with putting it in the oven again. This place also has a liquor store as well as darts and a pool tables. We left after a good hour and took what was left home. I would definitely suggest this place as a good spot to unwind.
… moreDonDada Browning
Amazing Experience! Years of traveling through the area It was our first time stopping in for pizza! FRESH and very TASTY!!!!!! We stop in not realizing the pizza side didn’t open til 5pm. A gentleman that was on the inside seen us at the door and came out and said that we can go through the bar side and order the What a delight! This will definitely be a monthly Pitt-Stop!
… moreMarc M
Me and my girlfriend had a really great time here when visiting from ft Lauderdale. Great and friendly bartender. Music was good, crowd was so fun.
… moreGary Hawkins
Great locals joint, Lauren is the best!
Give them your money!
… moreGive them your money!