Sirena Bazile
It was nice. Better than ok, but not the best it could be. This place has so much potential, it just didn’t completely mesh. Warm authentic welcoming and seating staff and servers are a must for a fine dining experience, but they were ok, overall. The deviled eggs were ok, the crab cakes were delicious, the calamari was a little too salty; but would’ve been very good without the extra salt, the steak was perfectlt made and delicious, the veggies were well seasoned but undercooked, and the potatoes hurt our feelings . The lavender lemon drop was the hit of the night, though. I may go back specifically for that drink! Soooo good! Lol. I loved the restaurant itself, the layout is different and curious and had an inviting ambiance.
… moreL
The server poured 187 ml bottles of Prosecco into a glass and took the bottles away even though there was more left. Happened twice—would’ve been better if they let us finish the bottles.
… moreSheryl Sanders
My son and daughter took me here for the second year in a row for my birthday. I love the ambience, staff is nice, not overwhelming friendly, decor is elegant, my dinner was excellent. I had the pasta with shrimp that was freshly cooked as ordered. I’m allergic to olive oil and they made the dish minus olive oil which was delicious! So their meals are not pre cooked ahead. For my day, they complemented me with a crème brûlée dessert with a candle. The cocktails were terrific. Our server was attentive and prompt. A very elegant place for romantic dates.
… moreShara Johnson
This eatery was on my Wanna Go list and now I’ve checked ✔️ that box. My experience was mixed. I enjoyed the ambience, the service and the crab cakes. The cocktails were on par. The food tasted a little bland. Needed some umph. We chose the dinner special and returned our plates mostly full.
… moreJiovanna Danielle Mamola
Our wedding day was the most beautiful and special day of our lives. Yesenia and everyone at the Sheldon Inn went above and beyond to make our day the best day ever. We were so fortunate to have toured the Sheldon Inn during one of the bridal showcases, where you can also get connected to fantastic vendors, like our incredible DJ Larry from Just Fresh Entertainment! The venue is picturesque, giving a modern rustic look mixed with a classic vineyard feel. The food and drinks are hands down some of our favorite things about this place but it’s truly the staff and everyone at Sheldon Inn that makes it the perfect wedding venue! Thank you Yesenia and Sheldon Inn for making our day so special!
… moreKevin Gaines
A quiet anniversary dinner was very pleasant. A reservation is highly recommended on a Friday evening. My wife booked it, and when we arrived on time, we were seated within 5 minutes. Off to the eastern end of the building there is a bar, and it was packed and lively that night, but the noise wasn’t overbearing. We were seated at a small booth, and the menus were personalized with an anniversary greeting! Very nice touch! The wait staff were very polite. There are demo bottles of the house wines at every table. The server explained that there’s a vineyard at the back of the restaurant and the wine is made onsite. I had a glass of the house Cabernet Sauvignon, and it was delicious. My wife ordered a steak dish and I ordered something involving a quarter chicken. Tasty, both of them. I’ve had better and worse, but they were both good. We had desserts as well. The most memorable part of the experience, truth be told, was the price. Two of everything: appetizers, a glass of wine and a cocktail, entrees, and desserts, with great wait service, in a well appointed but unpretentious dining room, set us back $155, not counting the tip, which was deservedly 25%. Very, very nice.
… moreMike
Overall disappointing. Service was great, nice location and ambience. Food was a letdown. Calamari to start with was very heavily coated to the point where all you tasted was deep fried batter. We had the mains of chicken and the special mahi mahi, both were cooked fine but under seasoned and bland.
… moreJenny
Went for an intimate celebration and our first time dinning. I’m not sure how I feel but I won’t be returning or recommending. Staff all around to manager was amazing from the hostess and manager.
Yes, the bread and house butter were amazing! The appetizers were better than the entree’s. The spicy pasta was high praised but it came to me very soft and broken which the chef confirmed. I unfortunately returned it for a special of the night. I was offered soup while waiting and desert on the house.
Bar was great. The best service and food of the night.
Atmosphere, was great. Casual attire but always best to dress up then dress down.
… moreLissette Galdamez
Had a good experience. Went to have a nice dinner and was not disappointed. Staff was friendly and service was good.
… moreMichelle Stiles
This was a beautiful restaurant. The weather was perfect so we sat outside. The food was quite delicious as well! We had brunch and you really couldn’t go wrong. Everything that we all ordered was delicious! It was that type of restaurant where you want to try everybody else’s food because it was so amazing!
… more