Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1644 Haskell Rd, Olean, NY 14760
Phone: (716) 373-3473
Website: https://www.randysfireside.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Randy’s Fireside: Rustic Restaurant in Olean, NY
Enjoy delicious food in a rustic atmosphere at Randy’s Fireside in Olean, NY. Visit our site to explore our menu.
Randy’s Fireside | Olean NY – Facebook
Take a ride to the Fireside from 11-3 for one of our 10 dollar lunches. Wing night starts at 4 with 90 cent wings and 7 dollar Schwings dine in only. Or come …
Randy’s Fireside, 1644 Haskell Rd, Olean, NY 14760, US – MapQuest
Serving Randy’s famous steak dinners, jumbo wings, half pound burgers, real steak hoagies. And Randy’s mom’s secret beer battered fish fry (Friday Only) Plus …
Reviews
XCIXGAMING
My wife and I are visiting from Ohio and decided to hit a local burger spot, we were not disappointed. I ordered the Gorilla Burger and my wife had the Pittsburg salad. My burger was massive, cooked perfectly and well seasoned, it was juicy and dare I say one of the best burgers I’ve ever had. My wife absolutely loved her salad and the medium buffalo sauce that the chicken was tossed in was very flavorful and tangy and not overly spicy. The chicken was juicy and obviously hand breaded. Our server was next level with her pleasant attitude and friendly demeanor. Next time we are in town we will definitely be coming back.
… moreKatia Schneider
Waited over an hour and ended up leaving without our food. Wasn’t even given a menu for 20 minutes after we were seated. They served everyone else around us, even those who came in after. Save your time and just go to the grocery store and cook yourself your own meal, it will honestly take less time.
… moreJeff Depew (JD)
We went for the fish fry on a Friday night. I got the large beer battered 1 for $18.95. It came w/ choice of potato, I got mashed w/ gravy. It also comes w/ a side salad or Mac salad, potato salad & cole slaw. U can swap out 1 if you would like & I did that. The fish was a great size portion & the salads were delicious also. We’ll definitely be back, the food was amazing & the service was great too
… moreR. B.
We has the surf n turf. Steak and grilled shrimp . It was delicious We also got the French onion soup, it was ok, but a little too salty for my taste. You should get some little scissors to cut the cheese in the soup,they work great. Our waitress was very good and they have some really great cooks, everything was seasoned great!!! Will definitely be back. Oh, the dessert with warm cake or brownies was huge and delicious, great for 2-4 people to share.
… morepyro323
My boss took us there for burgers on a Saturday, the server told us to seat ourselves. I ordered a bacon egg burger and fries. It was very good. It was really quiet in the restaurant. They had College football playing on the TV. Our meals came to $41.
… moreGary Sollars
Called before going, was told with family of 12 we would be seated as soon as we arrive. We had to wait 15 mins before a waiter even noticed.
Drinks order, took 45 until they arrived.
Food ordered took 1.5 hours until placed on the table. Half was wrong or way too seasoned. I’m guessing the guy was the owner, was told from him directly that the soup being over salted happens all the time , and they don’t know exactly what they are doing in the back. So why? Why are they making the food?
Also after being there 3 hours half waiting, was only asked once’s for refills.
Also without being told from the beginning or even on the menu watered down sodas are 3$ each.
Until this place has better and proper management I don’t recommend this place to anyone!!!!
… moreDrinks order, took 45 until they arrived.
Food ordered took 1.5 hours until placed on the table. Half was wrong or way too seasoned. I’m guessing the guy was the owner, was told from him directly that the soup being over salted happens all the time , and they don’t know exactly what they are doing in the back. So why? Why are they making the food?
Also after being there 3 hours half waiting, was only asked once’s for refills.
Also without being told from the beginning or even on the menu watered down sodas are 3$ each.
Until this place has better and proper management I don’t recommend this place to anyone!!!!
Daniel Donnelly
Very hospitable restaurant with good food a fair prices. Full bar with several beers on tap (none sampled during this review) and wines on selection. Furnishings cozy, including the titular fireside. Bathroom clean and waitstaff very friendly (many thanks to waitress Tirsha!). Parking unpaved directly outside, with space enough for thirty cars easy. In November 2021 the Cattaraugus County Libertarian Party hosted Larry Sharpe at this location.
… moreWilliam Anderson
After waiting 5 minutes I had to approach the bartender to be seated despite the “Please wait to be seated” sign. The place is filthy! Food on the floor, sticky seats and table.
I had pulled pork. Fair. Cole slaw was sour and warm. Wife had French dip – beef tasted old and tough.
Definitely not worth stopping in. Really needs to be cleaned up or closed!
… moreI had pulled pork. Fair. Cole slaw was sour and warm. Wife had French dip – beef tasted old and tough.
Definitely not worth stopping in. Really needs to be cleaned up or closed!
Leo C. Gibbons Jr.
Always a great experience here, we were on Harley ride and had Burgers this time.
… moreBryan May
Great food, great service! Looking forward to our next visit.
Back in town for Christmas. Even better meal this time. The fillet mignon was perfect. Love the pizza fire logs! Very generous with the very tasty dipping sauces. Best customer service I’ve ever experienced. If I could move here I’d eat here at least twice a week.
… moreBack in town for Christmas. Even better meal this time. The fillet mignon was perfect. Love the pizza fire logs! Very generous with the very tasty dipping sauces. Best customer service I’ve ever experienced. If I could move here I’d eat here at least twice a week.