Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Humble stand in City Market offering paninis & sandwiches with a variety of cheeses, meats & sauces.
Hours
| Monday | 7:30 AM–2 PM |
| Tuesday | 7:30 AM–2 PM |
| Wednesday | 7:30 AM–2 PM |
| Thursday | 7:30 AM–2 PM |
| Friday | 7:30 AM–2 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 211 N Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: (317) 385-7839
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cafe Olivia | Indianapolis IN – Facebook
Cafe Olivia, Indianapolis. 310 likes · 59 were here. Daily Specials Monday- Spicy Italian Sausage & Pasta,Tuesday – N Y City Deli Pastrami,Wednesday-…
Cafe Olivia | Visit Indy
Café Olivia, fondely referred to as a hidden gem across patron reviews, has been serving gourmet sandwiches from the City Market for 15 years.
Cafe Olivia, IL Paninoteca, the Sandwich shop – Reviews, Photos …
Cafe Olivia stands out as a quintessential sandwich shop, captivating patrons with its vibrant atmosphere and an impressive array of freshly crafted sandwiches.
Reviews
Justin K
The best sandwich shop in Indy. Rivaled only by Súbito at #2. I am fortunate enough to work in the Regions Tower where Cafe Olivia is located. I have ordered most of the sandwiches on the menu and everything is excellent. Whenever I have a client in the office and we need a fast lunch, I always take them here. Favorite sandwiches are the Verona and Milano.
The store is owned and operated by a lovely couple who do everything themselves. Their diligence and attention to detail is unrivaled. More even than most of the fine dining kitchens I worked in my youth. I have never seen someone take so much care in putting toppings on a sandwich. The result is not just delicious but incredibly consistent. Never had a bad experience.
Only downside is they can get busy at lunch rush 12:-12:30, but I’m always willing to wait for perfection.
… moreThe store is owned and operated by a lovely couple who do everything themselves. Their diligence and attention to detail is unrivaled. More even than most of the fine dining kitchens I worked in my youth. I have never seen someone take so much care in putting toppings on a sandwich. The result is not just delicious but incredibly consistent. Never had a bad experience.
Only downside is they can get busy at lunch rush 12:-12:30, but I’m always willing to wait for perfection.
Eve Tan
The best sandwich shop in Downtown Indy! I love their Cajun Turkey and Roast Pork sandwiches. So flavorful and delicious. They also have great coffee and fruity caffeine refreshers.
… moreSeth Halstead
This is a fantastic hidden gem! They used to be in the City Market, which closed for extensive renovations, and I didn’t realize they had moved to this new location in the Regions Bank lobby. The new location is beautiful and relaxing, and the food is still amazing. They obviously take pride in what they offer, and the result is great tasting sandwiches without compromise. The prices are very fair, especially considering the quality. If you show up and there is a line, your patience will be rewarded. They work very fast even though it’s only two of them, and they don’t cut any corners on quality even when busy. Enjoy your lunch!
… morepenny899
eaily the best sandwiches in the entire midwest. QUALITY ingredients, fast, clean— definitely needs to raise prices!! makes sense why it is so busy at lunch time :))
… moreJeffrey Koons
I’m lucky to have them in our office building (Regions Bank Building). GREAT sandwiches (don’t forget the pickle!), fast service, and super friendly. I feel like I’ve won the lottery when they have their potato salad. A very very tasty lottery!
… moreJasmine Long
The people who own this place are so sweet and the menu is great. They’re friendly, efficient, and the prices are very good considering the variety of sandwiches and the quality. They serve breakfast too and it hits the spot every time. Will keep in the rotation for the foreseeable future.
… moreChelsey Voegele
One of the best, if not THE best, sandwich place in downtown Indy. Their sandwiches are made with love and are SOOO good. My favorite is the prosciutto and mozzarella, it’s like it was kissed by a god.
… moreLauna Michelle
The corn beef Rubin is delicious, I highly recommend. They also have Dirty potato chips which are the best and very hard to find.
… moreAbby Wills
Amazing lunch spot! Sandwiches are great! Will definitely be back
… moreBobby C
Very good “standard deli”. Quick, friendly service and fresh, tasty sandwiches. Awesome spot for a quick lunch with awesome views!
… more