Casual chain featuring pizzas & sandwiches made with house-baked rolls.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2111 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362
Phone: (765) 529-8868
Website: https://mancinosnewcastle.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders
Mancino’s Pizza and Grinders were established in the late 1930’s by Samuel Mancino Sr., near St. Clair Shores, Michigan.
Mancino’s of New Castle – Facebook
Family friendly restaurant bringing quality service, pizza & grinders to the City of New Castle. Restaurant · (765) 529-8868.
Mancino’s Pizza and Grinders
A pizzeria with a bread bakers soul, creating the very best in pizza & grinders! With only the highest quality in meats, cheeses and vegetables.
Reviews
Michael Cecil
Jeremiah & Lensi have a done a great job in their years as owners. The atmosphere is always positive and inviting from the moment your feet step through the door. The environment is clean, the staff are friendly and the food is always hot and prepared fresh. They go out of their way to help the community in any way they can, from giving back and support.
The Cecil family will always be proud supporters of their establishment!!!
… moreThe Cecil family will always be proud supporters of their establishment!!!
Julie Achenbach
Update: the owner reach out to me through FB messenger and apologized and said he would be handling it. He was very kind and respectful.
I will be back to get pizza very soon.
Let me first start by saying I love your pizza. I was craving it so bad this evening. We live 45 minutes away and I can only get it on Sundays when we are in town. Tonight I called at 7:30pm and it rang at least 30 times with no answer. We drove to the restaurant and I walked in at 7:45 and tried to order a pizza and they said no because they were closing in 12 minutes. I understand that it would have been tight getting it done, but if they would have answered the phone at 7:30 they would have had plenty of time. This is not the first time this has happened.
Just a side note. We used to go with friends there almost every Sunday night (large party) but we can’t do that anymore due to you closing so early. I can imagine you would lose money staying open until 9-930 or even 10. Just a thought.
… moreI will be back to get pizza very soon.
Let me first start by saying I love your pizza. I was craving it so bad this evening. We live 45 minutes away and I can only get it on Sundays when we are in town. Tonight I called at 7:30pm and it rang at least 30 times with no answer. We drove to the restaurant and I walked in at 7:45 and tried to order a pizza and they said no because they were closing in 12 minutes. I understand that it would have been tight getting it done, but if they would have answered the phone at 7:30 they would have had plenty of time. This is not the first time this has happened.
Just a side note. We used to go with friends there almost every Sunday night (large party) but we can’t do that anymore due to you closing so early. I can imagine you would lose money staying open until 9-930 or even 10. Just a thought.
Roger Roberts, Jr.
Delicious grinders and pizza with a very wide variety of menu items and toppings. A great place for large parties since they have two large party rooms. Order at the counter, get your own drink, and the servers bring your order to your table. I’m a frequent visitor who is never disappointed.
… moreReasonable Citizen Reviews Indy
I was in town following a work event and I remembered trying a Mancino’s in Ft. Wayne last week that I thoroughly enjoyed. Naturally I was happy to see a location in New Castle as I was having difficulty finding a place that wasn’t a fast food chain.
I got the Italian grinder as it was delicious the first time around, figured I’d stay with what I liked as I wasn’t sure if it was the same business as the previous location. Fortunately it was. I had a great sandwich and even got to see kids celebrating in the dining room what looked like a championship victory. It brought me back to days past as a young kid. So I had a nice time. Would recommend.
—————————————–
@Julie Achenbach. I was writing my own review and saw your personal 1 star slop.
As a recent visitor to this community, I find your review not only disappointing but emblematic of a troubling world view that places personal convenience above basic respect for working people.
You claim to “love the pizza,” yet your affection seems conditional on the staff bending over backwards to accommodate your every whim, regardless of their posted hours, their workload, or their right to close on time like any other human being. You called at 7:30 and allegedly called twice a minute for 15 minutes until you marched in demanding a pizza be prepared. I can’t imagine living a life so detached from how regular people and businesses operate that I would behave like this.
This restaurant didn’t fail you. You failed to respect their boundaries. You failed to consider that those employees, who likely work long shifts on their feet, deserve the dignity of a timely closing and the ability to go home to their families. Your review reads less like feedback and more like a child’s tantrum thrown because the world didn’t rearrange itself around your gluttonous craving.
And your “side note” about bringing in a large party every Sunday. Spare us your thinly veiled threat. You’re seriously suggesting that your patronage should dictate their business hours, as if your presence is a gift they should reorganize their lives around. That’s not community-minded. That’s narcissism.
Restaurants are not vending machines. They are run by people who deserve compassion, not condescension. If you truly cared about this establishment, you’d respect its staff, its hours, and those who work there. Instead, you’ve weaponized a review to shame them for not sacrificing their time for your convenience. All so some assistant manager makes you feel important with a facebook replay. Pathetic.
Your pizza craving is not more important than someone else’s right to rest. If that is a dealbreaker for you, perhaps the problem isn’t the restaurant, it’s your embarrassing perspective.
Stay miserable.
Try the Italian grinder.
… moreI got the Italian grinder as it was delicious the first time around, figured I’d stay with what I liked as I wasn’t sure if it was the same business as the previous location. Fortunately it was. I had a great sandwich and even got to see kids celebrating in the dining room what looked like a championship victory. It brought me back to days past as a young kid. So I had a nice time. Would recommend.
—————————————–
@Julie Achenbach. I was writing my own review and saw your personal 1 star slop.
As a recent visitor to this community, I find your review not only disappointing but emblematic of a troubling world view that places personal convenience above basic respect for working people.
You claim to “love the pizza,” yet your affection seems conditional on the staff bending over backwards to accommodate your every whim, regardless of their posted hours, their workload, or their right to close on time like any other human being. You called at 7:30 and allegedly called twice a minute for 15 minutes until you marched in demanding a pizza be prepared. I can’t imagine living a life so detached from how regular people and businesses operate that I would behave like this.
This restaurant didn’t fail you. You failed to respect their boundaries. You failed to consider that those employees, who likely work long shifts on their feet, deserve the dignity of a timely closing and the ability to go home to their families. Your review reads less like feedback and more like a child’s tantrum thrown because the world didn’t rearrange itself around your gluttonous craving.
And your “side note” about bringing in a large party every Sunday. Spare us your thinly veiled threat. You’re seriously suggesting that your patronage should dictate their business hours, as if your presence is a gift they should reorganize their lives around. That’s not community-minded. That’s narcissism.
Restaurants are not vending machines. They are run by people who deserve compassion, not condescension. If you truly cared about this establishment, you’d respect its staff, its hours, and those who work there. Instead, you’ve weaponized a review to shame them for not sacrificing their time for your convenience. All so some assistant manager makes you feel important with a facebook replay. Pathetic.
Your pizza craving is not more important than someone else’s right to rest. If that is a dealbreaker for you, perhaps the problem isn’t the restaurant, it’s your embarrassing perspective.
Stay miserable.
Try the Italian grinder.
Jacob
I ordered Spaghetti Alfredo with Extra Extra sauce because who doesn’t like their Alfredo saucy and then I got this. I would never in my life look at this and think it looked good enough to server to someone. The noodles are hard and crunchy from being baked with almost no sauce. Even if I didn’t specifically order extra sauce this would still be sad.
… moreJ E
They have great food and service. I sure wish they sold Buffalo wings there because id eat there more often
… moreCarter Schlenz
The owners are great the staff is also very nice and welcoming. The food is awesome and filling. I had 7 pieces of cheese pizza, 1 breadstick with cheese, and a bowl of the superman ice cream. 10/10 definitely would recommend!
… moreRachel A
Had lunch here with a friend today. Got the pick 2 option 2 Topping slice of pizza (Pepperoni and Pineapple) with 1/4 Grinder (Roast Beef and More) .. made it a combo with 2 bread sticks and a drink… Food was delicious!!
… moreChristy Dawn Whipple
The food is really good and nice to have a variety in town. It’s always a bit busy and chaotic on Sundays and we always seem to find ourselves there with family on a Sunday. We definitely need to try coming during the week when things are a little quieter. The prices are fair, especially for the quality of the food. We’ve been a little frustrated with the service the past few times, but overall a good experience anyway.
… moreZhenay Newhouse
I love the cheese garlic bread.. plenty of seating. You have tables for four our larger parties.. it is clean and smells so delicious. If you pass taco bell then you passed Mancinos. They have 3 handicapped parking spots right in front of the door. They do not have automatic doors but they have double door entrance!! Love the food. Very cozy and friendly staff!!
… more