Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 89 S Union St, Spencerport, NY 14559
Phone: (585) 617-4279
Website: http://www.mccolleys.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
McColley’s
McColley’s is a Pub of the Isles built in the style of an old Irish cottage. McColley’s is the place to find good food, good drinks, and good friends.
McColley’s | Spencerport NY – Facebook
Opening at 10am tomorrow!!!! 3/17!! Breakfast options from 10am-12pm! Irish menu only tomorrow (no regular menu) No reservations!
McColley’s Irish Pub – Spencerport Area Chamber of Commerce, NY
McColley’s Irish Pub. Categories. Restaurant. 89 South Union St Spencerport NY 14559 · (585) 617-4279 · (585) 617-5031 · Visit Website. Share.
Reviews
Jenny Sauls
Absolutely loved this place! Came in to get a gift card for a st Patty’s day gathering I’m doing, it was our first time coming here . Had a couple drinks and some food. Everything was amazing! This place is great. Will definitely be coming back again.
… moreMike S
A cool Irish pub, with dining in the back. Each table in the dining area is separate from one another, which makes a nice intimate setting. The side room has TV to watch the Bills, or for a larger gathering. Great food, and vegetarian options are available as well. We had the chicken pot pie (9″ wide) and sweet potato Reuben, in the photos. Enjoy!
… morePaula Mitchell
Perfect date night, look forward to going back to sit in cute booths. Friendly service and food came out fast and HOT! Highly recommend both the fish fry and pot pie and suggest sharing due to large portions. Nice beer selection, many were listed as coming soon, so we will be back!
… moreDan Magin
Walked in the door and we were made to feel welcome. We were seated quickly and our waitress was very attentive. Ordered a bowl OG chicken Santa Fe soup. Good god! It was delicious. Had a couple pints and some poutine fries. Excellent. We will definitely be back. Good job McColleys.
… moreMarion
I have to say that eating at McColley’s last night was quite the pleasant experience. I had the Turkey Rueben which was the best I ever had. They use house roasted turkey and it truly makes a huge difference in flavor. My mom had the new menu item Pierogis, Kielbasa and Sauerkraut. Let me tell you how she devoured her meal, which is not very often that she does. The sauerkraut was perfect. Not to sour but still had a wonderful flavor. The servers are the best in the business. Very attentive and they anticipate your requests. My water glass was empty and I did not see the server to request a refill and within minutes she was right there with a full glass of ice water. What a pleasure it was to dine here. Will certainly be back many times over.
… moreCarl
My wife and I went here to try to solve the fish fry debate! Is the salt and vinegar chip crust better than the beer battered?
I got the salt and vinegar fish. I had super high hopes for this being I love a strong vinegar flavor. When it came out it looked great and you could see that they used crunched up chips for this. It was a good crunchy fish fry but I didn’t notice the salt and vinegar flavor. Overall it was good but I think I had my expectations of a vinegar punch to my face haha.
My wife got the regular beer battered fish fry. This too was a good fish fry.
We both loved their tartar sauce. It had a flavoring it in that made it stand out.
As for which one is better, I can’t decide. The chip one is crunchier. If you like a crunchy breaded fish get that one, if you like beer battered get the regular. I could eat either one and be happy.
I did get the corned beef hash as my side. I was expecting home fries type potatoes with corned beef. What I got was different – it was like a corned beef stuffing in a bowl. It was ok just not what I expected. I was choosing between this and the colcannon. I wish I chose the other but more because I’ve never had it before.
They had Rueben fritters and a Rueben baked potato on the appetizer menu I’d like to try, but my wife doesn’t like sauerkraut and I wouldn’t have ate the whole thing of either so I’ll save it for another time.
… moreI got the salt and vinegar fish. I had super high hopes for this being I love a strong vinegar flavor. When it came out it looked great and you could see that they used crunched up chips for this. It was a good crunchy fish fry but I didn’t notice the salt and vinegar flavor. Overall it was good but I think I had my expectations of a vinegar punch to my face haha.
My wife got the regular beer battered fish fry. This too was a good fish fry.
We both loved their tartar sauce. It had a flavoring it in that made it stand out.
As for which one is better, I can’t decide. The chip one is crunchier. If you like a crunchy breaded fish get that one, if you like beer battered get the regular. I could eat either one and be happy.
I did get the corned beef hash as my side. I was expecting home fries type potatoes with corned beef. What I got was different – it was like a corned beef stuffing in a bowl. It was ok just not what I expected. I was choosing between this and the colcannon. I wish I chose the other but more because I’ve never had it before.
They had Rueben fritters and a Rueben baked potato on the appetizer menu I’d like to try, but my wife doesn’t like sauerkraut and I wouldn’t have ate the whole thing of either so I’ll save it for another time.
Michelle Murphy
Little hidden gem! Place looks tiny from the front and it’s like Narnia inside! Keep walking through and you’ll find more rooms and more treasure! Lovely back bar that opens to the outside area! Food is incredible staff is friendly and knowledgeable. We drove 1300 mi around Ireland last October and visited many pubs, Atmosphere here is reminiscent of true Irish pub! A Must visit! Try the fried green tomatoes!!
… moreDave Swieton
We had traveled to Ireland this year and felt like we were back there as soon as we walked in the door. It had the same type of atmosphere. Plenty of room, food and service is good and they have music but not sure when. You can talk without yelling and feel relaxed. As we were leaving it was getting quite busy which tells you the locals really like this place.
We’ll be back
… moreWe’ll be back
Quinton Stone
Went there today for lunch. Very first time going and will for sure return. Service was the best! Food was great and a large menu. Loved the atmosphere as well. Our waitress Jenna was perfect. Best lobster bisque and BLT around. Tons of bacon and huge sandwich.
… moreJen Kearse
Even though the bar closes earlier than most, the bartenders are amazing (ask for Alvin). There’s a little book that customers can sit and write messages in so check that out while you’re there. If you looking for something a little more mature in the area compared to other options, this is a great choice.
… more