Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2445 S Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234
Phone: (920) 854-7997
Website: https://www.facebook.com/p/Carroll-House-100063522772874/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Carroll House | Sister Bay WI – Facebook
Carroll House, Sister Bay. 1594 likes · 2433 were here. Breakfast & Brunch Restaurant.
Carroll House – Door County Pulse
Carroll House Restaurants Phone (920) 854-7997 Physical Address 2445 S. Bay Shore Dr Sister Bay, WI 54234 Mailing Address 2445 S. Bay Shore Dr Sister Bay, WI …
Carroll House – Sister Bay Door County
Family operated nostalgic diner, around since 1957. Our famous Old Fashion Waffles are a must have! Come start a family tradition!
Reviews
leighjen2012
My boyfriend, now my fiance, and I always stop here and get breakfast during our Door County vacations. This visit was just as wonderful as the others. The staff was friendly and attentive. The food was phenomenal, as it arrived quickly, was perfectly cooked and just delicious! We are already looking forward to our next visit!
… moreMegan
My family and I stumbled upon this place for brunch and absolutely loved it! The service was friendly and helpful. Our food came out quicker than expected. I ordered the Door County cherry stuffed French toast, which was delicious and had great flavor. I also ordered a side of bacon. My Grandma ordered the bread pudding French toast and said that was very good as well. There are many menu options for breakfast and lunch. I would definitely come back and eat here again!
… moreLarry Robe
Wow! What can I say?
We came here after hearing the wait at Al Johnson’s was 1.5 – 2 hours. I wish we had made this our first stop to begin with!
Our party of 13 was sat in a reasonable amount of time without a reservation. Coffee cups were always full.
The Door County Cherry Stuffed French Toast was excellent – although admittedly, I added walnuts to mine and only got a half order.
The veggie croissant has an excellent flavor, was flaky, and perfectly cooked.
The cinnamon roll had a hard outer layer, but an amazing warm, well-flavored interior & top.
Others at the table had Chilaquiles, side order of hot salsa, breakfast burrito, corned beef hash, egg & cheese English muffin, etc. all menu items were enjoyed (with the exception of the hard exterior of the cinnamon roll).
The service was the “icing on top” AND we were able to easily split checks! Phenomenal all-around with top-notch food and service.
… moreWe came here after hearing the wait at Al Johnson’s was 1.5 – 2 hours. I wish we had made this our first stop to begin with!
Our party of 13 was sat in a reasonable amount of time without a reservation. Coffee cups were always full.
The Door County Cherry Stuffed French Toast was excellent – although admittedly, I added walnuts to mine and only got a half order.
The veggie croissant has an excellent flavor, was flaky, and perfectly cooked.
The cinnamon roll had a hard outer layer, but an amazing warm, well-flavored interior & top.
Others at the table had Chilaquiles, side order of hot salsa, breakfast burrito, corned beef hash, egg & cheese English muffin, etc. all menu items were enjoyed (with the exception of the hard exterior of the cinnamon roll).
The service was the “icing on top” AND we were able to easily split checks! Phenomenal all-around with top-notch food and service.
mzee75
We chose the Carol House restaurant as a back up because the place with the goats on the roof had a 95 minute wait.
It was a mixed bag experience. First of all, the serving staff are what is keeping this place afloat. They are quick, friendly, and attentive. Overall, five star service.
The dining room is tiny and cramped, with tables elbowed up next to each other. It is also very loud. We had to raise our voices most of the time to just hear each other across the small table.
Unfortunately, the food isn’t that great. I was stunned that an vegetable omelette could be almost completely devoid of flavor. The same was true for the Eggs Benedict. Shockingly, it was the most flavorless hollandaise sauce we’ve ever experienced. And, the hashbrowns were burnt to a crisp. My son’s pancakes were devoured quickly, and they were generous with the chocolate chips.
The best thing we could say about the food is that it was edible. There are some hits and some misses, and this felt like a miss on our vacation.
… moreIt was a mixed bag experience. First of all, the serving staff are what is keeping this place afloat. They are quick, friendly, and attentive. Overall, five star service.
The dining room is tiny and cramped, with tables elbowed up next to each other. It is also very loud. We had to raise our voices most of the time to just hear each other across the small table.
Unfortunately, the food isn’t that great. I was stunned that an vegetable omelette could be almost completely devoid of flavor. The same was true for the Eggs Benedict. Shockingly, it was the most flavorless hollandaise sauce we’ve ever experienced. And, the hashbrowns were burnt to a crisp. My son’s pancakes were devoured quickly, and they were generous with the chocolate chips.
The best thing we could say about the food is that it was edible. There are some hits and some misses, and this felt like a miss on our vacation.
Robert Cyrus
A nice, quaint breakfast stop! My wife ordered the Door County Cherry Stuffed waffle and I ordered Uncle Roo’s Hashbrowns with 2 eggs, over easy. The food and service was fabulous, and very reasonable. There were quite a few “regulars” having breakfast there as well. Kind of fun hearing the discussions about current events and fishing. Totally loved it! Would highly recommend this place!
… moreJohnny Irish
First time ever to Door county. The food at Carroll’s was incredible. The food came out within 10 mins. My wife and I loved the food. Myself being a breakfast guy loved it! It really hit the spot. We will come again tomorrow before heading home.
… moreChristopher Frey
Nice homey diner with a good selection of breakfast and lunch. The food was solid but nothing in particular went above and beyond. The service was efficient yet pleasant and staff were all very nice.
… moreNicholas
Delicious breakfast spot. Fast Friendly service. Didn’t have to wait long for a table or our food. The Door County Cherry stuffed Waffles were amazing. It looks like they have a garden out back with patio seating but may be under construction at the time of this review. Beautiful restaurant and well kept grounds.
… morecarly mcconnell
Such a cute cozy and great breakfast spot! The service and food were incredible, the cherry stuffed french toast/waffle was the best thing I’ve ever had in my life
… morePatrick Provart
We stayed around the corner at the Birchwood, and the staff highly recommended Carroll House. They were right. On a Sunday morning when the more “Touristy” places had a 90-minute wait for a table for two, Carrol House got us in with no wait. I’m informed the potato pancakes were excellent, and I had a half order of the cherry stuff waffles, with a side of hash browns. The only thing better than the food was the service. (And the fact that 90% of the customers appeared to be locals and not tourists like me)
… more