Chelsea Sisneros
Great service. The waitress was hilarious and helpful. The food was great! The homemade crust was insane. Toppings were great! We did off menu and did Guy on a Buffalo. Drinks were reasonably priced.
… moreJacob Evans
The pizza buffet and salad bar was awesome. They had a very diverse selection of premium specialty pizzas at all times. It was a nice touch to also offer made to order pasta as well! We hope to be back very soon!
… moreCathy Tieman
We ordered carry out and our food was hot and on time. My husband ordered the carnivore pizza which was excellent. Great flavor, ample toppings and the crust was perfect. 8 on the other hand ordered the Italian insalada. I had never heard of a pizza like this and to tell you the truth, I wasn’t that impressed. Don’t get me wrong, it was okay but I won’t be ordering it again.
… moreTravis Abbott
Well, clean and cold. Friendly staff, LONG wait, 1/2 full and 45Mins to get our pizza. We also saw then turn 3 tables away at 7:10 to 7:30 claiming a 30 min wait and they close at 8 so they just ignored them until they left. Guess they don’t like to make money. Also they serve box wine intresting. Weird crust and tasteless pizza imo
… moreShaun Gwaltney
Stopped in here after a conference and had the pleasure of of have Daniel (aka) Birddog as our waiter he was hilarious personable and definitely kept us laughing. We stopped in due to great reviews and we were not disappointed. I didn’t even know a robot was going to deliver our food till we seen that bad boy in action . Great experience and highly recommended give this place a go.
… moreEva Heimberger
I mean WOW! I didn’t know pizza could get any better .. But it did. Thin crust was crispy and yummy, with flavor caves for days! You can tell everything is prepared with love and care. If you’re lucky you might even get a little show from Mr.Pepperoni himself. If you’ve been before then you know all about it, if you haven’t do yourself a favor and stop in, get a pizza, meet a robot, have a cold beer and enjoy the atmosphere of this special little place on the square. I doubt you’ll regret it.
… moreAnnie Wallace
Don’t expect real pizzerias to turn orders around quick. Be patient for good food.
First of all, both the thin crust and hand-tossed crust are perfect. I could eat just the crust. The carnivore pizza was loaded with meat and flavorful. The chicken alfredo was not as good, but still good. The garlic was overwhelming in full cloves and piles of mince on top. The waitress offered jalapeño dust and I recommend spicy lovers give it a try.
The service was very friendly. Crash, the robot, was fun to watch delivering pizzas.
I will be back!
… moreDerrick Rieke
Finally got to experience Pepperoni Bill’s for the first time tonight. We have been trying for over 4 years. We frequent the lake often. My sister has always claimed Peperoni Bills is one of her favorite restaurants down here. Every time we have attempted to go they have been closed, even though Google and or their website would say they were open. I understand there has been a lot that has happened over the past 2 years with Covid challenges and now staffing and shortage of supplies. Tonight we waited an hour to be seated and were told our only options were 3 hand tossed pizzas or the salad bar because everything else was sold out. The staff was friendly and the pizza was good, but with our issues of this restaurant never being open and the very limited menu tonight we are giving 2 stars. Hopefully on a future trip down we will have a better experience and be able to try more of the menu items.
… moreBrett Frasier
Great pizza and salad bar. Make sure to call ahead of time to make sure they’re open. Only problem is I wish they were open for lunch at least one day a week as I tend to work most evenings.
… moreTj Wilmering
We loved our server, and her robot assistant! The pizza and garlic bread were great. We loved the history of the lake area on display around the room.
… more