Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Pie Hole, Marc Bynum’s Farmingdale Pizzeria, Closes – Patch
FARMINGDALE, NY — The Pie Hole of Farmingdale closed its 850b Main Street digs, chef Marc Bynum announced on Instagram. Bynum encouraged people …
The Pie Hole in Farmingdale closes – Newsday
… New York pies with thoroughly Bynumized toppings such as the Caribbean Queen (jerk chicken, grilled pineapple, plantain and hibiscus BBQ …
The Pie Hole – CLOSED, 850 Main St, # B, Farmingdale, NY 11735 …
Get more information for The Pie Hole in Farmingdale, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Olivia Gordon
The freshness speaks volumes. One of the things that sets apart the ok and great pizza places in LI is quality. Really creative flavors; not overwhelmed with salt and really fresh/quality ingredients. Crust has great flavor. They have traditional and pepperoni for the traditionalist but do yourself a favor and try something new. The flavor combos are very creative. Will definitely be back to try their other foods as well.
… moreEverythings Right
I picked 3 slices… so much selection! Loved the variety of choices. Caribbean Queen(BillyOcean) , Lil Tunechi(LilWayne) & Sicilian (the Biggie) ALL. were outstanding! And i loved the names! The service was also excellent. I look forward to returning & trying the other variety of pizza & the chicken wings! YUM!! Highly recommend!
… moreQuentin Hodges
TL;DR: Flavor-infused pizza, wings, and a whole lot more.
Located adjacent to a busy street and nestled behind a seasonal ice spot, TPH has a modern interior with two tables and a traditional pizza counter with their amazing pies on display for customers to agony over.
I started with a slice of Caribbean Queen and one of their Not Knots which is served with a cup of marinara for dipping. The pizza dough was perfect, soft with doughy pockets and areas of crispness. There was a great mixture of sweet and salty thanks to the combination jerk chicken, bbq sauce, and plantains, pineapple. Yes, on a pizza.
To wash it all down I tried a bottle of the slightly sweet iced tea. Normally I prefer my beverages sweeter, but the sweetness of the toppings balanced it out. It also worked to my advantage because I couldn’t help myself and ordered Dem Wings, which brought a bowl of sticky sweet heat. Honestly the gochujang sauce could be bottled and sold separately. It’s that good. I expected six wings but received eight. I asked the owner why and he said that they normally receive larger wings from the supplier and added two extra to make up for their smaller size. Solid move.
There’s several other items on the menu that I need to try (Banana Pudding!), so I’ll definitely be back.
… moreLocated adjacent to a busy street and nestled behind a seasonal ice spot, TPH has a modern interior with two tables and a traditional pizza counter with their amazing pies on display for customers to agony over.
I started with a slice of Caribbean Queen and one of their Not Knots which is served with a cup of marinara for dipping. The pizza dough was perfect, soft with doughy pockets and areas of crispness. There was a great mixture of sweet and salty thanks to the combination jerk chicken, bbq sauce, and plantains, pineapple. Yes, on a pizza.
To wash it all down I tried a bottle of the slightly sweet iced tea. Normally I prefer my beverages sweeter, but the sweetness of the toppings balanced it out. It also worked to my advantage because I couldn’t help myself and ordered Dem Wings, which brought a bowl of sticky sweet heat. Honestly the gochujang sauce could be bottled and sold separately. It’s that good. I expected six wings but received eight. I asked the owner why and he said that they normally receive larger wings from the supplier and added two extra to make up for their smaller size. Solid move.
There’s several other items on the menu that I need to try (Banana Pudding!), so I’ll definitely be back.
Steven
Stopped by for lunch. I really wasn’t expecting much because of the turnover at the location and there’s a lot of basic pizza around but, wow, was I wrong.
I had a short rib and collard greens slice and it was off the charts. The meat was tender and delicious and there was plenty of it on the slice. The greens were charred nicely and the tips of the pieces had a little crisp to them.
The crust, my goodness. The crust may be the best pizza crust I’ve ever had. It was a really big crust but it was light and airy yet crispy at the same time.
Looking forward to trying more at The Pie Hole.
… moreI had a short rib and collard greens slice and it was off the charts. The meat was tender and delicious and there was plenty of it on the slice. The greens were charred nicely and the tips of the pieces had a little crisp to them.
The crust, my goodness. The crust may be the best pizza crust I’ve ever had. It was a really big crust but it was light and airy yet crispy at the same time.
Looking forward to trying more at The Pie Hole.
Jj Prete
Stopped by the get a quick slice and was blown away by the selection and different slices available compared to other pizza places. The owner was very friendly, service was quick and the Psvchedelic (shrooms) slice was amazing. I will definitely be back to try some other options as everything on the menu sounds amazing. Highly recommend.
… moreSandwich
There is not one slice that will make you say I wish I got something else. No contest The BEST specialty pizza I have ever had! Oh, and did I mention the fried chicken? Yeah, get that too!
… moreJason Nabel
Pizza toppings like you’ve never seen made by Long Islands own Rock star chef Marc Bynum. Original and delicious!!!
… moreAndrea B
We got a few different slices at closing and they were all delicious! The Caribbean Queen slice was outstanding! Welcome back and good luck to Chef Marc Bynum!
… moreMichael Rimpel
I knew about this place cause I’ve eaten at the owner’s food truck. Definitely go on a Friday to get the oxtail slice. Also the jerk chicken slice is good but it has more of a BBQ taste vs jerk flavor.
… moreEdward H
Amazing spot! Wish I took photos of the food before we left to share with the world. Close to Farmingdale college and we stopped during a break in my sons tournament. The Caribbean Princess and Biggie slices were nothing short of amazing. Friendly service and great vibe too!
… more