Related Web Results
Carey On Main | Sheridan IN – Facebook
… other handheld favorites. . Follow · . Details. . Page · Sports Bar. . 96% recommend (36 Reviews). Posts. Carey On Main updated their status. Jan 28, 2022 .
Carey on Main – CLOSED, 401 S Main St, Sheridan, IN 46069, US
Get more information for Carey on Main in Sheridan, IN. See reviews, map … Los Agaves Grill. Mexican restaurant. “Our family went to Los Agaves for an …
Carey On Main | Sheridan IN – Facebook
… favorites. . Follow · . Details. . Page · Sports Bar. . 401 S Main St, Sheridan, IN, United States, Indiana. . (317) 647-2110. . Closed now. .
Reviews
Nick O’Brien
Good food, great drinks, fun times. Staff are friendly. This is a 21+ place, but is smoke-free. The big burgers are my personal favorite along with the potato skins. One time both of my potato products (skins + baked) were undercooked, but otherwise everything has been good over ~20 visits. They had a car show over the summer months, and other events, plus karaoke.
… moreMedia Manley
The staff was great. The only problem was the cook didn’t know how to make a Patty Melt. It was a burger on two slices of rye with a slather of thousand island. Not grilled, no onions.
I have had other items on the menu with no problems. I wanted to go an educate the cook but I was having a good time.
Hopefully this will be remedied and I will be back!
… moreI have had other items on the menu with no problems. I wanted to go an educate the cook but I was having a good time.
Hopefully this will be remedied and I will be back!
Tiffany Strater
Great bar with a nice menu. The phone ringing the whole time we were there seems to speak to the locals love of the bar as well. I personally like the breaded mushrooms as a starter and the chicago beef as my dinner but will say that the tacos and tenderloin sandwich are also quite good.
… moreLori Cornell
Midwestern small-town bar with a full menu. Chef salad was HUGE & fresh. Service was quick & friendly. Fun karaoke on Fridays & Saturdays! Appears they have a patio for warmer months.
… moreTara McGlothlin
I had the tenderloin and it was AMAZING. I consider myself a connoisseur of tenderloin and this is one of the best I’ve had. Stephanie was my server and she was great. Worth the trip to this small town grill.
… moreCarol Strater
Good drinks and good food! Had the 3 soft tacos (steak or chix…I had steak). Loaded with lettuce tomatoes and cheese. Comes with sour cream and salsa. I ordered chopped onions on the side since a taco isn’t a taco without onions! Cody, our bartender and server, was on point and aimed to please! Awesome Monday nite dinner! Ordered a Long Island Iced Tea and wasn’t disappointed…either you know how to make them or you don’t and Cody definitely knew just the right combo. Juke box playing great music. A hidden gem in the middle of Sheridan!
… moreTed Lobdell
Great place! Steak was awesome ! Wife had salmon, she said it was perfect! 32oz beer $5.00 , it was a good date !
… moreAaron Scott
Really a diamond in the rough! Very clean and tidy bar on the inside, but you’d never know by looking at it on the outside… the only downside is the food was a bit bland. Need more flavors in the food.
… moreLuke Standridge
Really great place to enjoy a drink with friends! The food and atmosphere is top notch as well! Highly recommended!
… moreJim Russell
My burger I had with the Sriracha honey fries was very good, highly recommended. Will definitely eat here again
… more