Social Profile: ![]()
… View more
Cones, ice cream cakes & other frozen treats are served at this homey neighborhood fixture.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1025 Straight Path, West Babylon, NY 11704
Phone: (631) 669-3020
Website: https://www.facebook.com/stoehrersoldfashionedicecream/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Old Fashioned Ice Cream | West Babylon NY – Facebook
Call today to pre-order or just stop in – We’re open every day 12pm to 10pm. Call 631-669-3020. Located at 1025 Straight Path, W. Babylon, Exit 36S just off of …
Old Fashioned Ice Cream Shoppe (@oldfashionedicecream)
Located at 1025 Straight Path, W Babylon, just off Exit 36S of the SSP. You …
Old Fashioned Ice Cream – Waze
Driving directions. Old Fashioned Ice Cream1025 Straight Path, West Babylon, NY 11704, USA. Old Fashioned Ice Cream. 1025 Straight Path, West Babylon, NY 11704, …
Product
Reviews
Nataliia T.
My family and I travel frequently and frequent various ice cream shops. We don’t eat ice cream from regular stores; we prefer to buy it from farm stands or specialty ice cream parlors. This time, I chose this shop. It was Sunday, and the line was crowded; the line even started outside, but it moved quickly. The place is very modest, without much decor; I found it quite uninviting. The service was average. The ice cream selection was decent, and the prices were average. The kids and I chose three different flavors: coconut, mango, and pecan. The pecan and coconut were too sweet for our tastes, and I didn’t really like the mango either; it lacked the tartness you usually get with mango. Overall, I recommend visiting.
… moreRebecca Dean
Easily one of the best ice creams on Long Island. Super rich, super creamy, so delicious. I had the Banana Cookie and loved it. We also love the Grapenut and Espresso flavors.
Really nicely decorated cakes too!
… moreReally nicely decorated cakes too!
Justine E
Calling all vegans or dairy-free folks to try out this spot!! They have some of the best vegan ice cream options on Long Island. They rotate their options, but they usually carry vegan vanilla soft serve and a second option like strawberry or pistachio. These are so creamy and delicious. They have occasionally have dole whip as well. They have vegan chocolate covered bananas. They can also make those mini sundaes or chocolate saucers dairy-free/vegan ahead of time for birthday parties. They have a variety of vegan toppings like sprinkles, nuts, chocolate/strawberry dip, etc. please support this spot if you’re ever in the area.
… moreMarisa Passaro
I’m definitely want to come back to try more of their speciality flavors. The cookie butter ice cream was great! My fiancé got the tres leches/strawberry swirl. He said the strawberry was great but the tres leches could’ve used more flavor.
… moreElizabeth S
The girl who waited on me today was very friendly and helpful! The way she scooped the ice cream was like an art, she got all four flavors perfectly triangles in the container so you dont have to go down laters for different flavors! I ordered a bunch of things, all of them delicious! Looking forward to going back to try more flavors. Highly recommend!
… moreDonna Nguyen
The workers are so nice and the ice was so yummy I love this ice cream
… moreMayra Hernandez
This was our first time visiting OFIC and it is very quaint and well received by the surrounding community. It was a terribly long wait to finish our order. It was bustling but not overly busy to support such a delay. The staff was just so very slow in turning the orders over. The ice cream tastes fresh and they had a great variety of flavors that seem to rotate consistently. I will give this place another try on a weekend day to see if there is a difference in quality of service.
… moreJ Nolan
Best ice cream flavor selections, pleasant staff and beautiful delicious custom made ice cream cakes. Best Old Fashion Ice Cream around!
… moreTim Walsh
Great little local ice cream shop! We stopped in on an unseasonably hot October day to get cones. Rainbow sherbet and chocolate chocolate chip both hit the spot.
Good value for the cones and the ice cream was good. One thing I wish they had would be tables or benches.
… moreGood value for the cones and the ice cream was good. One thing I wish they had would be tables or benches.
Muaz Rahman
Drove a long distance because Google showed this place as open, only to arrive and find it closed. Very frustrating and a complete waste of time. Updating business hours online is basic customer service. Disappointed.
Please update your hours to avoid putting others through the same situation.
… morePlease update your hours to avoid putting others through the same situation.