kelly morrison
Not sure if it was the bartender/waitress first day or what. Took 10 or 15 minutes after we arrived for her to take our order. She kept forgetting stuff we asked for..to bring our drinks,take our order , bring forks, extra napkins, ranch Parmesan) We was very kind and mindful but hopefully they will train her better, hopefully more training and more experience is all that she was needing. Pizza was mediocre but tasted fresh, the cheese curds were $10 they were decent but we only received maybe a handful or less. There was only 3 other tables occupied, 2 of which already had their food.
… moreBubba Logan
Wanted lunch amd stopped in to grab a pizza and Shelby was amazing plus the food was excellent will definitely stop by when in town again
… moredaniel groh
Ate in at Pickwick Pizza tonight. The beer was cold, the Greek salad was perfect, but….the pizza tasted like it had been sitting under a heat lamp for 8 hours. I’ve had better gas station pizza then what I was served tonight.
Its sad because they use to have the best pizza in town as far as I’m concerned. This is the second time the pizza was terrible. I hope they can find a new pizza maker. Ill give them another chance, but 3 strikes and they’re out!
… moreLaura McKenzie
Over the weekend we purchased a large all meat pizza for pickup. When my husband got back, we opened the box and the whole pizza was burnt. The cheese on top and the crust was black! I couldn’t believe they even boxed that thing and sold it to us for $30.00! I called them and told them what was going on. She apologized and said bring it back and we will make you a new one. I even heard her tell the guy in the kitchen to make another meat pizza.. So my husband went back out and picked it up. He got distracted and didn’t look at it. When he got back, I opened the box and was speechless! It was a plain pepperoni pizza with all the pepperonis just thrown in the middle of it. Also, it was not a large. The crust was so thin that it would break in half when you picked it up. Obviously they use frozen pizza crusts. I’ve had frozen pizzas in my freezer that were better than that! We were SO pissed off! I called them back to tell them and they said sorry, and that was it. I’ve never been so disappointed in their quality and customer service!! We were so done! We just angrily tried to eat it and it tasted awful! I had one slice and ended up throwing it back in the box. Seven dollars a slice! I’m not one to usually one to complain but I just couldn’t believe it!
… moreDouglas Hoff
Very friendly service, really interesting and fun atmosphere.
Cheese curds were amazing. All meat pizza was delicious.
… moreDebbra Springsteen
I did an online order so can’t say much about the atmosphere but the pizza was really good and it was really fast. I’ll definitely be back.
… moreChristine Drury Hill
This place is so cool! Little bitty place but the PIZZA…SO GOOD! It’s a thinner crust and it’s LOADED DOWN with toppings. The service was good the people were nice…We will be returning.
… moreJohn Lancaster
Stopped in while at the park for a conference. The pizza was really good and the Italian sandwich was also delicious. Our server, Micaiah, was very friendly and took care of our needs. You should definitely check this place out.
… morePatrick McClure
What a gem in this little town. The pizza is surprisingly good. Quality cheese and pepperoni. The mushrooms were good. Had the Cheese Curds, pretty average but by no means bad. The gal working was super busy but got everything done quickly and was available when needed. Would definitely recommend it if you’re looking for a good tavern style pizza.
… moreJoy Ashford
Always delicious and sweet ladies working there, plan on another visit while family are here this week.
… more