Thomas Dieber
From the crispy crust, zesty home made sauce, quality cheese, to the quality topping ingredients, its rare you find a pizza place that still cares about the quality of their pizza these days and theese guys have hit the nail on the head. I can’t wait to try their whole menu! Highly recommend this tucked away gem!
… moreJoe B
I moved up here from Bergen county and couldn’t find a pizza that reminded me of home, there were a few other people in this spot before (i ordered out of convenience) but then Vaccas came into that spot and i felt at home with the first bite. We’ve ordered a lot off the menu and couldn’t be happier that they moved in. Their pizza is fantastic, their diavolo sauce is outstanding, i want it jarred so i can use it on everything (they do sell their sauce jarred, so there’s that) the cold antipasto is plentiful. They only deliver up the mountain, so if you’re in the lowlands, you should stop up and give them a try. All around happy they’re here.
… moreDave F
I stopped here after hiking at nearby Wawayanda State Park. We ordered a whole pie with pepperoni, sausage, and onions. The pepperoni was obviously good. Sausage can be tricky. You never know what you’re gonna get from place to place. But this was good Italian sausage, sliced thin enough that it was crispy from being cooked. Same with the onions. Some places cut em too thick and they don’t cook through. These were thin and perfect. And the crust was some of the best I’ve had. Even after being closed up in a box, it didn’t get soggy. It tasted good enough to eat it all.
There are fancier places, but those places are usually bland. This was a proper old school NJ/NY style pie, and that’s what i want in my pizza. It’s unexpected to find such a legit place all the way up this far north, but I’m glad i found it. I’ll be back next time I’m in the area for sure.
… moreDorée Mortillo
Love this place! My husband only gets pizza from here now, although it’s a drive for us! I love that he grows his own basil!! So smart! Calzone and cannolis are also great!!!
… moreBenjamin Jones
A fine made pizza in area, freshly homemade cannoli, and look at this calzone!!! It’s huge, soft, delicious and on my next order 🙂
… moreC. D.
Today I tried the fried mushrooms for the fist time… an boy were they amazing. The pizza is phenomenal… the wings were spectacular…..
… moreLen Bilello
on a fall motorycle ride to see some foliage my friend and I got lost and stumbled across Vacca’s Pizza and we are glad we did. The owner and staff were super friendly and the pizza is as delicious as here in Manhattan and less expensive. Would highly recommend to anyone passing through or who lives in the area!
Note: sadly their restrooms are not available to the public but it’s the fault of the town/state and not the management. So if you need to go, this won’t be the place.
… moreEllen Pedrick
We are planning to move to the hewitt area. Stopped in for pizza and will definately be going back there. Jaon you make an outrageous pie !!! The pizza had the taste of the old corner pizzeria where I grew up. You can actually taste the fresh ingredients. And the crust was superb. Looking foward to trying other meals that they offer. Would HIGHLY recommend the pizza. ….ps nice to have meant the owner Jason and also brenda !.
… moreJohn
Didn’t order thin crust… arrived cold and tasted horrible! Very disappointed! Done with place
… morebob donaldson
Without a doubt, the best pizza in West Milford! If it wasn’t up the mountain, Vesuvio would be in trouble! You must give them a try and you will not be disappointed. Nice people as well.
… more