Address and Contact Information
Address: 1018 Waverly Ave, Holtsville, NY 11742
Phone: (631) 569-4693
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Firehouse Bagels Delivery Menu | 1018 Waverly Avenue Holtsville
Order delivery or pickup from Firehouse Bagels in Holtsville! View Firehouse Bagels’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with …
Firehouse Bagels, 1018 Waverly Ave, Holtsville, NY 11742, US
Firehouse Bagels is a beloved bakery located in Holtsville, NY, known for its delicious bagels and breakfast sandwiches. With a loyal following of customers …
Order Firehouse Bagels – Holtsville, NY Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Firehouse Bagels at 1018 Waverly Avenue in Holtsville. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Reviews
Nick Salvatore
Great food and great service! The egg sandwich meal is a great deal. They are fast and friendly! Love this place 10/10
… moreDavid Solomon
Local bagel house for fresh delicious rolls and bagels at genuinely affordable prices. Their everything bagel with scallion cream cheese was a standout to me. I’m a regular customer for buttered roll with coffee.
Not a café or restaurant. Authentic and clean place.
… moreNot a café or restaurant. Authentic and clean place.
Evan Nangle
Firehouse Bagels has potential, but it often misses the mark. I’ve been here a handful of times, and while the service is generally friendly and the menu looks promising, the food is almost always subpar. Bagels can be hit or miss. Sometimes too dense, sometimes not fresh. Sandwiches are okay, but nothing that really stands out or keeps me coming back regularly. It’s convenient if you’re in the area and need a quick bite, but don’t expect anything exceptional.
… moreTejas Singh
My bagel was so good. It was enough to fill me up. The staff members were very kind. I had a salted bagel from this store and it was perfection. The diversity of the breakfast meal was amazing. I even found Japanese Cheetos! Overall, I had a great experience and would love to come back next time.
… moreJason
The bagels are look werid and they taste gross and taste like a gas station bagel
… moreAndy Buckmaster
Awesome breakfast spot. Got the breakfast special which came with a coffee for about $6. Highly recommend this place.
… moreChris C
I guess they’ve started selling their bagels in gas stations and 7-11’s now. I usually get a bagel with my coffee at sevs in the morning, and I noticed recently (within the last month or two, that I noticed anyway) that the packaging for the bagels looked different. I didn’t really give it much more than a quick glance until I found the first hair on my bagel… long, black hair… I’m blonde and short haired. Ok, it happens, no big deal. Until I found one on a second bagel the next day, AT A DIFFERENT 7-11! This one was baked in, too. Like, seeds were popping off as I pulled the hair, it was under them. Gross, but maybe bad luck…. then I found another one today, a week after the last one… so that’s 3 out of 8 bagels with long, black, nasty hairs in them. I’m done. No more firehouse bagels for me.
… moreIt’sWeird InHere
Dude my onion bagel with cream cheese was SOOOOO GOOD. Also had a turkey blt it was amazing. The dude serving us was quick and kind.
– I take this back I guess that was a one time deal. The food tastes like dishwater.
… more– I take this back I guess that was a one time deal. The food tastes like dishwater.
Dave Wu
Cool, no nonsense bagel shop, cozy and feels like walking in your grandma’s kitchen. The bagels are akin to the Montreal style bagel minus the wood burning oven. They have a good balance of chewy tenderness and while they do have rolls, eggs and Boars Head products for sandwiches and the like, the bagels are great and deserve to be eaten simply with butter or cream cheese.
… moreWastedTalent
I went here for the first time yesterday to pick up breakfast sandwiches for my family. 3 sandwiches: 2- 2 eggs on a bagel with bacon, salt, and pepper, and 1- 2 eggs on a roll with bacon, cheese, and salt and pepper.
How did they screw it up? Let’s talk about it. None of the sandwiches had bacon. None of them had 2 eggs. I paid for 2 eggs on each sandwich and only got 1 egg on each.
Not an auspicious start for a first time visit.
… moreHow did they screw it up? Let’s talk about it. None of the sandwiches had bacon. None of them had 2 eggs. I paid for 2 eggs on each sandwich and only got 1 egg on each.
Not an auspicious start for a first time visit.