Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5 N Luther Ave, Arcadia, FL 34266
Phone: (863) 722-0185
Website: http://www.brothersfisharcadia.net/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Brother’s Fish House Arcadia | Arcadia FL – Facebook
“Hey there, food lovers! Our menu is bursting with flavors waiting to be explored! Find us tucked away at 5 N Luther Ave, just behind the Amoco gas station. If …
Brothers Fish: Best Fresh Seafood in Arcadia
Appetizers · Hush Puppies (8) · Crab & Seafood Cake · Clam Strips (4oz) · Breaded Onion Rings · Breaded Mushrooms · Corn Nuggets · Sweet Potato Fries with Cinnamon …
Brother’s Fish House – 5 N Luther Ave, Arcadia, FL, 34266 – MapQuest
Reviews · Great spot with plenty of options on the menu The calamari was delicious, and the service was on point–our waitress was very attentive and friendly.
Reviews
Amber B
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Great spot with lots of menu options The calamari was delicious, and the service was awesome with a very attentive waitress. Portions are generous!
The coconut shrimp was a great pair with the marmalade, but the seared scallops with fresh garlic were hands down the best 10/10.
We’ll definitely be back!
… moreGreat spot with lots of menu options The calamari was delicious, and the service was awesome with a very attentive waitress. Portions are generous!
The coconut shrimp was a great pair with the marmalade, but the seared scallops with fresh garlic were hands down the best 10/10.
We’ll definitely be back!
Erica Ducette
We have been here several times and are always so pleased with the food and the service! The blackened basa was very tasty and fresh. I loved the lemon cream sauce that came with it, too! I’ve had the clam pasta and it was just as tasty. The servers make you feel right at home. They take hospitality to the next level. I already ate at their Port Charlotte location, so I was ecstatic when they opened up a location so close to home. The prices are reasonable and the food came out quick and hot! Love this spot ❤️
… moreCarol Osborne
Delish coconut shrimp w hush puppies & cole slaw. Orange Marmalade dipping sauce w horseradish & chili flakes & fresh lemon.
Red snapper blackened perfect w lemon tarragon sauce.
Unassuming place about 12 tables. Clean friendly. Definitely suggest this place.
… moreRed snapper blackened perfect w lemon tarragon sauce.
Unassuming place about 12 tables. Clean friendly. Definitely suggest this place.
Kristi Scudera
First and most important, the food is amazing! The homemade ranch, the homemade Cole slaw, every entree with the homemade sauces… just fabulous! I’ve eaten there twice this past week alone! The service, everyone is super nice. They’re attentive, just a tad slow. But, it’s because it’s a very small place and it gets busy so I understand that. Atmosphere is just an ok for me. I only dislike that the bathroom is so close to the dining area. One person blowing it up and it’ll ruin your meal. But, until that happens, I love this place!
… moreDebbie Schwind
My new favorite place in Arcadia. Great selection of seafood. All cooked fresh and comes out hot. Great staff. I am already looking forward to the next time.
… moreLinda Peloquin
Our food was delicious. The clam chowder was especially wonderful. The shrimp was fresh and perfectly cooked.Our waitress was lovely and friendly. We will definitely be back.
… moreLori Hoogendoorn
Waited at least 10 minutes to be acknowledged for drinks. Food took over 40 min to get. Fries had seasoning to spicy for 3 yr old. And could not offer dessert as they were completely out. Otherwise food was ok. 2 of the 4 people in the group liked the food. I was not a fan.
… moreJody Amick
My husband and I had lunch here last weekend. It was Sunday so it was crowded and the food order took longer than expected but it was worth the wait. I had the shrimp tacos and my hubby had fish and chips. The waitress was so nice and apologized for the wait. We will definitely return for a meal. So yummy!
… moreJeff Martin
Dined on 12/29/2025
I had Brother Seafood Pasta and my wife had grilled Scallops and shrimp. My pasta was full of seafood (clams, mussels, Shrimp, calamari, and fish), the pasta was cook well, and the broth season nicely. My wife’s scallops and grilled shrimp were season well and cook perfectly. Portions were nice size in my opinion based on the price. Two dinners and a glass of wine $52. Our server Kaylie was very attentive and the other serve didn’t hesitate to help. Just a very good experience. We will be going back more frequently. Don’t expect a flashy entrance or decor, just good service and food!
… moreI had Brother Seafood Pasta and my wife had grilled Scallops and shrimp. My pasta was full of seafood (clams, mussels, Shrimp, calamari, and fish), the pasta was cook well, and the broth season nicely. My wife’s scallops and grilled shrimp were season well and cook perfectly. Portions were nice size in my opinion based on the price. Two dinners and a glass of wine $52. Our server Kaylie was very attentive and the other serve didn’t hesitate to help. Just a very good experience. We will be going back more frequently. Don’t expect a flashy entrance or decor, just good service and food!
MASeahawk
Our first visit and it won’t be our last. The restaurant is spotless. Even the sauce bottles are clean. The wait staff is personable and efficient. Fish and shrimp were delicious- hot, fresh and crisp. Looking forward to trying more things on the menu.
… more