Mr.D’s Pizza

  4.3 – 32 reviews  $ • Takeout Restaurant

✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in Mr.D’s Pizza 53219



Address and Contact Information

Address: 5919 W Burnham St, West Allis, WI 53219

Phone: (414) 800-5006


Related Web Results

Mr. D’s Pizza – Menu, prices, restaurant reviews – Facebook

2423 S 6th St, Milwaukee, WI 53215. … Cover Photo: Mr. D’s Pizza’s photo. … arent with us anymore, you are missing out on the BEST pizza in Wisconsin!!!

Dining: The Mystery of Mr. D’s Pizza – Urban Milwaukee

Past locations include Mr. D’s Pizza at 2038 W. Greenfield Ave., … the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo …

Mr.D’s Pizza – West Allis, WI Restaurant | Menu + Delivery

Order with Seamless to support your local restaurants! View menu and reviews for Mr.D’s Pizza in West Allis, plus popular items & reviews.


Ted Pyle
This is my first time ordering from Mr, D’s–and it won’t be the last! Great pizza all the way around–sauce, cheese, pepperoni & crust. Outstanding!!
… more
Ahnoki Doxtator
Really really excellent Pizza! For those that have it mixed up the Original MrD’s was on S 21st St and W Greenfield Ave. There is only a field there now. Yes it was the best Pizza in Milwaukee in the 90s, at least for me and many other southsiders. This pizza for me is exactly the same if not super close. The only difference would be I remember Mr D’s having a darker sauce. I would put this pizza and Fidencio’s up there at the top. Any true Milwaukeean will remember Mr D’s and love this pizza just as well! All the Fillipos, Balestreri, DeMarini’s, Zafiros, Maria’s and so on best watch out because if the word gets out about Mr D’s pizza and it being just as good as the original, everyone else might have to close their doors! I love the simple menu! Oh that crust, I mean that crust is soooooo delicious and crunchy! You know what I just finished my pizza, maybe I’ll just order another one. I think my family is wondering where all the pizza went! Haha just kidding I left them some, but I do need to order more! Sooo good.
… more
Dave Laurich
Pizza is ok at best. Anyone saying this is the same has D’s on Greenfield. Was either hammered when they tried it or never really had the original . Because the flavor is not even close. I grew up on that pizza and this one is a big let down.
… more
Cyndee Farmham
While their pizza is fairly good this is the third time I ordered and the third time my order was messed up. I didn’t call the first two times and while I was calm in registering my complaint the young man hung up on me. If that’s how they want to treat thier customers I will not be going back there.
… more
Todd Massey
Super legit Pizza! One of the best I’ve had in the area. There is some hupla about the naming rights but regardless the pizza is Fantastic! Add this spot to your list.
… more
Dell S
Ever since Mr. D’s Pizza close down on national Avenue I’ve been searching for a decent pizza. I don’t know if this Mr. D’s has any association with the original two locations, but this is the best pizza that I have had in the last few years.
… more
Christina Edwards
For years, I’ve been looking for amazing pizza with a very specific taste. Years ago, I was a regular patron of Pasquale’s Pizza, and was devastated when they closed. Mr. D’s has the specific taste I’ve been looking for! Soooooo gooooood!
… more
Shari Larson
So happy to get Mr. D’s again. Been looking for a good pizza ever since they left.I will never order a pizza from anywhere else!Thank you to whomever brought it back!
… more
Becky Q
Very good pizza I can’t add a photo because I ate it.
… more
tina roman
I started as a customer of the original Mr. D’s on 21st & Greenfield decades ago, then when they opened a new location on National in West Allis. I was heart broken when they closed. I was so happy to see this location. Tried them for the first time & was sooooo happy to find the same pizza I grew up on. I drove in from Brookfield for the others & will now be driving in for this pizza. Nothing in Brookfield come close to the taste & quality.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment