We eat at the Mayflower about once every two years, mostly out of convenience due to the awesome location. The taste and quality of the food is average at best. The prices are good in comparison to the portion. The coleslaw is cut so fine, the consistency is mush. The customer service is subpar. Our waitress was more so dressed for bedtime. She also forgot our drinks, so we had to remind her. The carrot cake was GREAT! Overall, Mayflower is okay to eat at sometimes, just not a favorite eatery.
Went for lunch, the service was great, the was good, minus the crab cakes. I’m only taking one star because everything else was hot and fresh. Maryland crab cake lover here, a bad crab cake is a death toll. The waiter saved the day by being gracious and immediately exchanging my crab cakes for more delicious flaky white fish. The huss puppies looked like onion rings, but I promise you they were good, and no onion taste at all, thank goodness.
Honestly this place is super over hyped. But from what I can tell this particular Mayflower isn’t the best I’ll have to try another and see how it is.This one brought me out cold food that wasn’t seasoned the best at all. Just very underwhelming seafood. This is even after having lowered my expectations since it was so far from the cost.
On the day that we stopped, the restaurant was very short staffed. The woman that was running the register left due to a DIF. I was really surprised at how fast the service was and how quickly we received our orders that were piping hot! Kudos to all the wonderful workers. We will definitely be stopping there again. The food was really good!
This was my husband first time eating at a Mayflower restaurant and he was highly impressed with the service and how delicious the food was..not to mention it didn’t to take long !!! He is ready to go again!!!!
Prices have doubled. Food was cold and bland. I was even charged to use my card 3%. No warning until you get to the register to pay. Having to pay over $60 for 4 people and not enjoy the food was disappointing. The staff however was nice.Which is why they get 2 stars. My family had been going here since I was a kid, so around 20 years. This was my first time back since covid started. Unless things change, we won’t be back. Which is sad because this use to be the go to spot for seafood.
Food was hot and delicious, service was fast and great, we visited on my birthday and the waiter gave me a free cluster of crab legs for my bday!
First time visiting the Mayflower. The food was real good & service was great! Only downfall….the restrooms smell HORRIBLE!!! You can smell them in the lobby. I don’t know if they have a septic issue or what. I would suggest investing in some better restrooms. Other than that, everything was great!
Slow seating. Server was prompt and friendly. Soup and salad were great, jumbo shrimps were delicious. Unfortunately, the fried chicken strips were so rubbery, I couldn’t even bite into them. I was so disappointed I left them at the table. Didn’t complain since owner would think I want something for nothing. Instead, I’m posting my review and never going back again.
Food was good. Only complaint the toppings for the loaded baked potato come on the side and the potato wasn’t hot enough to melt the cheese.