Fantasy Diner and Ice Cream Parlor

  4.3 – 502 reviews  $ • Restaurant

Social Profile:

Health and Safety:  Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits · 



Address and Contact Information

Address: 5873 Hamilton Middletown Rd, Middletown, OH 45044

Phone: (513) 360-7097



Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Fantasy Diner and Ice Cream Parlor – Home | Facebook

5873 Hamilton Middletown Rd., Middletown, OH 45044. Get Directions · Rating · 4.9. (164 reviews) · 2,113 people checked in here · (513) 360-7097 · [email protected] …

Fantasy Diner and Ice Cream Parlor – Zmenu

View the online menu of Fantasy Diner and Ice Cream Parlor and other restaurants in Middletown, Ohio.

Fantasy Diner and Ice Cream Parlor – Middletown, OH – Yelp

32 reviews of Fantasy Diner and Ice Cream Parlor “Excellent food and service! The Open-Faced Roast Beef w/home-made green beans was AMAZING, …

Reviews & Complaints

Stephen Francia
Absolutely perfect little “diner”. Good food that comes out hot and fresh. Great service. Incredible selection including “special” blue plate type meals and pies. Known for their chicken “balls” as well. Menu items that are “fried” have incredibly no “grease/oil” around them – a good thing! The outside looks rough – almost abandoned, but don’t let that deter you. Side entrance on the right of the building, and is handicap accessible. Go and enjoy!
… more
Love Honny
I literally drive past every week and never knew about this place. OMG!!! The Potato Bomb was delish! Buffalo Chicken Pizza is highly recommended and the banana pudding Ice cream was amazing! Oh and the sweet tea, hands down best in the Midwest!!!!!! Service was excellent, place was clean. We will definitely be back to this hidden gem!
… more
Lisa Mofford
When my husband and I visit our daughter’s family we usually go out to eat. We were getting tired of the chain restaurants. So I used Google maps on the way and scrolled through the typical chains and came across The Fantasy Diner. The menu looked promising and so did the pictures of the food. We were greeted when we came in and was told to sit wherever we liked. Our waitress Nova was super nice and did a great job. We ordered breakfast and it was fantastic. Pancakes, biscuits & gravy, home fries and potato cakes was ordered among other things. It tasted like made from scratch. If anyone remembers Fantasy Farm in Middletown the diner was the gift shop. The diner was really nice. We will most definitely go there again. We want to try lunch and dinner.
… more
Tim Grill
Took my mother for my first visit. I’m a Lesourdsville/Americana and fantasy farm collector so the character of the restaurant made me warm and fuzzy. I had a pork tenderloin w/home fries while mom had fish w/ribbon fries & cole slaw. Everything was delicious. The server worked hard and was very personable. I’ll be back VERY soon.
… more
Dillon Crawford
The inside is very nice looking. The food is extremely good, I recommend getting pancakes, bacon, and toast. If your going in for breakfast. My favorite was the bacon cause it’s not crunchy, or dry. You’ll see what I mean if you go there for yourself.
… more
Darren Copley
The servers were nice and really great. My kids loved it, but my food was cold and not fully cooked. Food is a little pricy too but that’s not a huge deal for a small diner.
… more
Matt Thomas
We stopped by this weekend and we’re pleasantly surprised. Best cheeseburger I have had on a while. Menu looks good, can’t wait to try more.
… more
Crystal Fordyce
Cute diner with a homey feel. The servers are sweet and do an excellent job. The food is good and the pie is awesome. Really a great hidden gem!
… more
Shelly Amburgey
Nope. Hair in my pancakes today 04/09/22. Showed too waitress and this wasn’t taken off bill and sons taco salad he said wasn’t eatable per cheese that was on it. Really hoped this little place would have worked out. Best thing about visit was the nostalgia.
… more
chantele davis
Went there this morning, there is no sign to alter of where main entrance is. Went in was greeted told to sit wherever, placed my coat down went to bathroom washed my hands. When returned there was not a menu or silverware on my table. I sit and waited and street 10 minutes no one attended me and they were loudly in kitchen just hanging out. Very disappointing. I just walked out
… more
… Load more reviews

Leave a Comment

Please rate