Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
Menu
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Big Jim’s Pizzeria – New Milford – Menu & Hours – Order Delivery
Cheese Pizza. Plain Cheese Pie. $17.65 · One Topping Pizza. $21.68 · One Half Topping Pizza. One topping on half of the pie. $19.67 · Two Toppings Pizza. $24.55 …
Big Jim’s Pizzeria | New Milford NJ – Facebook
to regular service (pickup and delivery) for the day. We apologize for any inconvenience, and we would like to thank our customers who placed the catering …
Big Jim’s Pizzeria – Pizza Delivery New Milford, NJ – Slice
Big Jim’s Pizzeria is located at 281 Main St, New Milford, NJ 07646. What are the hours for Big Jim’s Pizzeria? Answer: Big Jim’s Pizzeria is open every day of …
Reviews
Colleen Sotiryadis
I grew up in New Milford, Big Jim’s pizza is the absolute BEST pizza ever!!! I now live on the North Shore of Long Island for the past 11 years and have yet to find pizza that comes close to Big Jims. My entire family agrees. He gets a 10 out of 10 in my opinion. We miss it! Colleen O’Leary Sotiryadis.
… moreDana Rubin
I have been coming to Big Jim’s for over 40 years and the owner Jimmy was always reasonable and fair. New ownership must be very petty.
… moreLeslie Lane
Every time I place an order, it’s made fresh and in the time they say. I enjoy their plain cheese pie. There is something so simple and soulful about it. Thank you, Big Jims
… moreFrancisco Marrero (Franky)
First time giving this place a try. Ordered a Sicilian pie. Have to say it was the best Sicilian I’ve had in about 25 years.
… moreBell McGough
I ordered calamari and it was horrible. I was chewy and and nasty. I was afraid to eat it bec it seems like not a real food. The thin Pizza was not thin at all. Was so unhappy. Not coming back ever.I can’t even put a star bec the food was that bad.
… moreCactus Jack
I honestly don’t see the hype. The pizza dough the taste the sauce nothing feels special. I believe it was better years ago unfortunately. I bought a pie yesterday and I really wanted to give 4 stars but I couldn’t I eat pizza almost everyday and if I was to rate it 1 -10 it would be a 6.4 pizza review @daveportnoy.
… moreLilly Cannarozzi
Don’t order their bar pie unless you enjoy eating cheese melted on a whole wheat tortilla, which the menu describes as “special dough”. extremely weird and genuinely unsure why you would serve this
… moreLeigh Lehman
Big Jim’s pizza is great – we think the best pizza in NJ. The people at Jim’s are the nicest and so accommodating. Don’t use the Slice online ordering as they add a 20% surcharge – just call Big Jim’s directly.
… moreAndy Puzak
Hi Jeff the pizza that we got for you was five stars and I hope you remember me I bought you the lottery ticket so have a great day and we’ll be customers for a long time to come thank you Andy Puzak
… moreFoxy Cotton (FoxyCotton)
I grew up in New Milford, My family lived in this town as far back as my Great Grandparents, we loved Big Jim’s, until Jim left.
… more